I watched the movie last night, and it did not disappoint. Aside from the powerful special effects that are strange but not annoying, the makers of the movie also offer their own reading of the great novel. Their reading seems to be that the narrator, Nick Carraway, is gay and hopelessly in love with Gatsby.
In order to support this reading, they change the plot in a variety of major ways. Nick’s semi-affair with Jordan is erased completely, Nick spends the better half of a decade after Gatsby’s death mourning his passing because – and this is an insistent motif- Carraway will never meet anybody as special as Gatsby ever again, both Nick and Gatsby are portrayed in a way that deprives them of all sexuality (which in the mainstream US entertainment is the most common way of hinting at homosexuality), etc. This is not my reading of the novel (enter “Great Gatsby” into the blog’s search engine to see mine) but I found it interesting.
The only real problem I saw in the movie was that the actors are a little too long in the tooth for their parts. Dicaprio works very hard to portray a much younger man and he isn’t half-bad but you can’t erase a 40-year-old face, body, and body language no matter how hard you try. Or at least not with DiCaprio’s degree of acting giftedness. The actress playing Daisy is not only very weak, but also has this extremely wrinkly neck that made all scenes where she was trying to portray youthful naivete quite clumsy.
Toby Maguire, the actor who plays Nick Carraway, has been forever typecast. A group of 50-year-old women in the audience yelled “Spiderman!” the moment he appeared on the screen. The actor didn’t help the viewers forget his most famous part as he kept adopting Spiderman’s trademark poses and facial expressions. The homoeroticism of the Spiderman series played into the queer reading of The Great Gatsby offered in the movie perfectly.
Overall, the movie is highly entertaining, a lot more comedic than the original novel, and curiously filmed. I recommend it as a good summer movie-going experience.