This is a scholarly book that I got for review. I rarely write here about the books I review professionally but I’m so in love with this one that I have to mention it. Hombres en movimiento is the second book I’m reviewing this year. The first one was so bad that I did something I never do and missed the deadline because I had no idea what to say about it in a polite, scholarly way. When I finally wrote and submitted it, my sister told me to withdraw it because it was so harsh. But it was accepted so eagerly I couldn’t do that.
But González-Allende’s book was easy to write about because it’s brilliant. It’s about the ways in which the trauma of emigration shatters male identity. It’s rare that we see any criticism that isn’t completely, gushingly and pathetically celebratory of migration as an unqualified and indisputable good. And this scholar wasn’t intimidated by that and only caved minimally to the slogan of “let’s mimic Charles Koch as much as possible!” that seems to animate so many academics.
The book is beautifully structured and very well written. It was a delight to read because it’s fresh and not boring. Books on masculinity are rarely good because they tend to be painfully predictable. But this one was a revelation on every page.
I’m so excited to see kick-ass scholarship on an important topic.