People on campus are in a state of panic over the SI chatbot that students can use to write essays. This should be a clue to retire the at-home essays for undergraduates. I did it a long time ago because it’s a useless exercise.
Usually, the students write an essay at the end of the course, hand it in, and the course ends. No learning happens. Many professors don’t even read the essays. Those who do and leave detailed comments waste their time because nobody reads those comments. It’s all a massive waste of time.
Instead, I have students write essays in my presence over two weeks. This means six hours of actual writing where I stand over each student and point out the errors as they write. For my Cervantes course, we did it over 3 weeks. Nine hours total. It took us a whole week to write a good first paragraph. And it worked. Not a single student – and these are graduating seniors – had the foggiest idea of how to do it. Years of writing essays, and they never had gotten a chance to find out what professors actually meant by “write an essay.” Only after I spoke to each one individually and guided them did it finally work.
Obviously, this can only happen in small classes. In large lecture courses, you can’t do it. Such courses should forego the essay and do something else.
The AI bot isn’t an enemy. It’s a friend that gives us a chance to rethink one of the outdated, useless staples of education. The essay, the book report, and the “presentation” based on copy-pasted crap from Wikipedia should go away forever. I don’t allow any presentations with text on a screen. Students can show images if they absolutely insist on doing so but words on a screen aren’t allowed. Whatever you want to say can be delivered orally with no visual aides. During a presentation, they speak for 15 or 20 minutes. No reading is allowed. In language courses, this is very useful.
Like this:
Like Loading...