Putin is going to demand NATO withdrawal to its 1997 borders in Ukraine peace talks as a key condition, he wants no NATO troops in Finland, Lithuania, Estonia and Poland and cites this as a key condition for starting the war in Ukraine-Telegraph

Okay, but what is he offering in return? We’ve all heard his demands many times over, so this is not much of a news update. What is the offer?

Don’t bother asking AI. I did, and there’s nothing. AI told me what Putin might offer, but that is neither interesting nor serious.

We will now spend weeks discussing whether NATO should withdraw from these countries or not, but that discussion is completely pointless and vapid, as there is nothing that is actually on offer in return. Based on this, I can only conclude that this is not a negotiation strategy but a tantrum.

27 responses to “Not a Negotiation Strategy”

  1.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Why does NATO still exist?

    Walnut

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      It’s a very successful money laundering scheme. Lots of people get lots of payouts.

      Like

      1.  Avatar
        Anonymous

        I agree.

        Walnut

        Liked by 1 person

    2.  Avatar
      Anonymous

      >”Why does NATO still exist?”

      ANSWER: To keep dictators like Putin from simply walking into neighboring countries like Ukraine — and for almost 80 years, NATO has kept Russia at bay without the West having to fight a world war.

      Dreidel

      Like

      1. Clarissa Avatar

        Seeing as Putin simply walked into Ukraine, I wouldn’t say it’s been extremely successful.

        Like

      2.  Avatar
        Anonymous

        Dreidel, I down-voted your comment because NATO was put together solely to stop the (USSR) from Invading Europe. That was its mandate, that was its sole reason for being.

        Once the USSR collapsed in 1989 it should have been disbanded after a period of say 5 years to make sure the USSR didn’t pop back up.

        The fact that it not only did not disband, but then spent the next 30-ish years expanding Eastward tells us that this organization is filled with people who want to keep their power, keep the money flowing, and oh yes want to ensure there is always an enemy that is (threatening the world and Europe in general.) So as to justify their existence.

        If you had answered as you did up until 1989 you would have had a point. After 1994 your point has no legs to stand upon. Frankly if I was in Putin’s shoes I would be extremely concerned about the aggressive nature of NATO and their Eastward expansion, and would be doing everything I could to put as many guns and bunkers on the borders as possible.

        I would also be doing my best to retake any former soviet territories to make damn well sure there is a buffer zone between Moscow and the lunatics in NATO.

        Frankly I blame the Ukrainian war on Europe more than I do anyone else. NATO’s aggressive policies pretty much guaranteed Russia’s actions. Just like how the European leadership are now openly talking about starting a war against Russia because obviously Russia is going to invade Europe. Please note, these are the same people who have laughed and mocked Russia for not winning in Ukraine after however many years this war has been going on.

        You can’t have it both ways. Either Russia is going to invade and it is inevitable, or they cannot invade because of incompetence. Choose one and stick to it.

        Either way, NATO should have been shut down thirty years ago, and Europe should have spent those decades rebuilding their own militiaries instead of relying on us for the bulk of the defense force.

        • – W

        Like

        1. Clarissa Avatar

          For the trillionth time, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has absolutely nothing whatsoever with “NATO expansion”.

          Once you can no longer adjust your thinking based on new information coming in, that’s when your brain begins to die.

          Like

        2. cliff arroyo Avatar

          “NATO and their Eastward expansion”

          How does NATO “expand” into a country that doesn”t want it?

          Like

          1. Clarissa Avatar

            Here I am, wasting my time explaining the importance of the nation-state when people long ago abandoned even the capacity to think in terms of nations and national sovereignty.

            Like

        3. cliff arroyo Avatar

          “Once the USSR collapsed in 1989 it should have been disbanded”

          The USSR collapsed later, in 1991. And within two years there was sectarian war in the Balkans and in 1994 russia began a brutal military operation in Chechnya…

          Like

          1. Clarissa Avatar

            Yeah… There was no time longer than just a few months when Russia was not waging a war of aggression against some of its neighbors. As I keep saying, it’s okay not to know about that. It’s okay not to have any interest. But what is the point of having opinions if you haven’t taken the trouble to inform yourself? Why is it even interesting to have opinions on a subject that is so indifferent to you?

            It is sheer lunacy for countries in Europe not to form military alliances to protect from Russia. NATO has turned into a sham and a money-laundering operation, but there absolutely need to be military alliances. All Russia does is export death. It’s been a source of extreme dysfunction in the world for 109 years. This it is not okay not to know, because this is a very basic fact of world history.

            Like

            1.  Avatar
              Anonymous

              From the top. I never said NATO expanded into countries that didn’t want it. I said they expanded eastward and kept doing so long after their reason of being the USSR collapsed.

              I further pointed out that if I was in charge of Russia this would have made me extremely wary and would have been building up as many defenses as I could and attempted to grab whatever territory I could to act as a buffer state between Moscow and NATO.

              My point of NATO should have been disbanded still stands. Its mandate was solely to defend Europe in particular and the rest of the world in practice from the USSR. The USSR collapsed into the dustbin of history 35 years ago. NATO should have disbanded shortly after with its mandate having run its course.

              I understand those of you from Europe see Russia as the Boogieman. I also understand how those who lived in the Cold War period likely have an unending hatred from Russia.

              I don’t care. As an American NATO is an abomination to me. For 77 years it has demanded that we be involved in Europe’s problems. Of that 77 years it was only legitimate for about 42 years. Which means that it should have been disbanded for nearly half the time its been around.

              No I have been steadfast from the very beginning. The Western Hemisphere is ours and we should not be garrisoning the rest of the world and declaring Pax Americana. It has lead to far to many so called leaders in America deciding they want to Empire build, and far to many leaders of Europe doing stupid stuff because America will back them due to us being stuck in NATO.

              Europe should be left to solve its own problems. And step one is for them to rebuild their armies. Now I will be fair to Clarissa I do agree its lunacy for an European nation to try to fight Russia by its lonesome. So yes I do agree defensive alliances are needed.

              However the US should not be part of it. Europe like the Middle East, Like Asia, and Like Africa should not be of our concern. We have land that we were supposed to rule and maintain and that is the Western Hemisphere. We have essentially abandoned our duties in order to maintain a Pax American everywhere else.

              Frankly from my point of view, the governments of Europe are failing. They can no longer even “manage the decline” as one British politician put it about they way they govern Britain. And so they are looking for a war with Russia to maintain their power and control. F. Them all. If Europe wants to fight with Russia, let Europe do so alone.

              As for my last point I stated I blame Europe more than anyone else for the mess in Ukraine. I arrive at this point from two directions.

              First European leaders have been saber rattling at Russia for decades now. They have been doing so knowing that NATO or rather the US protected them from the consequences of their actions. Did Russia saber rattle back, yes, but Russia is not the one constantly proclaiming that they are peaceful democratic nations.

              Second a basic google search will show that Ukraine has tried to join NATO multiple times starting all the way back in 2002. Again I do not blame Ukraine for this. As noted above defensive alliances required. I do blame NATO for not having disbanded beforehand. This action would threaten Russia by putting NATO even closer to their capital if it had succeeded. No major country would ever allow this to take place.

              For the US it would be the equivalent of Cuba or Canada joining the USSR back when the USSR was still about. Oh yea Cuba kind of did. Funny how we are still punishing them how many decades after the USSR fell? As I said no major country can allow that sort of action to take place near its capital. Again I do not blame Ukraine. Their actions were logical. I blame Europe as they knew how this would force Russia to act.

              All in all NATO should have disbanded back in the 90s. Its far to late now, and I fear WWIII is about to go from a proxy war to an open war, and frankly for the US there was dozens of off ramps over the last few decades. But no we had to support our allies in NATO and thus we are now facing nuclear war once more. What fun, what joy.

              • – W

              Like

              1. v07 Avatar
                v07

                W, did I understand it correctly that you believe the only dangerous thing about the USSR was that it was communist? So when it ceased to be communist the danger just disappeared? This is a complete disregard towards Russia’s imperial history…

                On the original topic – there is no rule that all negotiations have to include both sticks and carrots. Perhaps Putin believes that he can manage with using only the sticks. Or, more likely, he may believe that the carrot is the possibility to do business as before 2014. Is he wrong? Even now Europe spends billions each year on Russian hydrocarbons. And Europe is losing Russian market to the Chinese.

                Like

              2. Clarissa Avatar

                Did you see that yesterday Putin got to talk with the Finns, and once again he started lecturing them about the pechenegs? What an absolute moron.

                Like

              3. v07 Avatar
                v07

                I am bit disappointed with the Finns. They should have hung the phone on him.

                Like

              4. Clarissa Avatar

                True. But on the other hand, maybe it was a slow day and they wanted to get entertained by his comedy routine.

                Like

              5.  Avatar
                Anonymous

                v07, no you seemed to have missed my point entirely, twice over even.

                Allow me to demonstrate my point to try to make it more clear.

                When a government falls and a new government rises you must treat said government as a new entity.

                If this was not the case France should still be treated as a pariah due to Napoleon. Germany should still be blacklisted due to Bismark and later Hitler. Mexico for Santa Anna. England for numerous if not most of its various governments and kings. The Norse countries for the vikings. Mongolia for Gengkis Khan. Japan for the Empire of Japan. Italy for The Roman Empire, and on and on and on until most of the world is covered in one way shape or another.

                Yet somehow after the USSR fell and a new government of Russia arose it was treated as if it was a continuation of the USSR. Now I can already see the accusations of “well its the same people in the government.” So what? The same was true in literally every one of the cases I listed above up to and including Germany.

                Now I understand it seems like I am defending Russia. I am not. I am attacking NATO. I am attacking the European leaders who are using my country as a thug in order to get their way. I am attacking the so called leaders of my country who are acting like the US of A should be an Empire. Who are forgetting that Empires always collapse and once they do it has never once gone well for said empire afterward.

                As for your second accusation, I have not spoken about communism in this section once. I have been deliberately avoiding doing so as I was focusing on NATO and the fact that NATO’s whole purpose ended 35 years ago and we are still stuck paying for it. If I decided to speak about communism the topic would spiral wildly out of control which is something I am trying to avoid.

                • – W

                Like

  2. cliff arroyo Avatar

    “What is the offer?”

    Of course it’s a stalling tactic and nothing else. The purpose is to delay things so they can kill more Ukrainians and destroy more infrastructure while westerners scramble around trying to figure outhow to respond.

    Many westerners in decision making positions are pathetically attached to the idea that russia is driven by rationality and that messages from russia mean something that can be responded to.

    Like

  3. cliff arroyo Avatar

    OT: More traditional Christian values on display in russia as already HIV rates are rising in over 20 regions…

    Beefeater (@Beefeater_Fella) ·

    In other news..

    The HIV epidemic has spread to almost 30 regions of Russia and has extended beyond high-risk groups, according to Rospotrebnadzor (the Federal Service for Surveillance on Consumer Rights Protection and Human Wellbeing).

    The number of people living with HIV… pic.twitter.com/ETCIbd4wp8

    View on X

    Like

    1.  Avatar
      Anonymous

      In the last years of the Soviet Union, the spread of the HIV was a major scandal that undermined the legitimacy of the state, now it is business as usual.

      Like

  4. cliff arroyo Avatar

    “the only dangerous thing about the USSR was that it was communist”

    Many rational westerners tend to think of the USSR as a temporary manic episode and after the 1991 collapse they assume russia became rational. Partly this is projection and partly they look at nearby countries who are a bit more rational and how fast they abandoned soviet ways as soon as they could and project that onto russia.

    And then there are those who just hate the west for…. some reason and think of the CIA and NATO as all powerful evil forces or think that Churchill was worse than Hitler and Stalin put together.

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      It was not communist. It was socialist: the Union of the Soviet Socialist Republics. Second, the idea that the system of economic relations is the most important thing about the country is the definition of Marxism.

      In reality, Marx made a mistake here, and even the neo-Marxists have long ago accepted this. The economy is not the defining thing for everything. Government ownership over the means of production is indeed bad, but it is not the worst thing. When Russia changed its economic system, it did not change spiritually.

      Once again, we have to ask who really won the Cold War when even the most conservative people in the West have accepted Marxism as the foundation of their thinking.

      Like

  5. cliff arroyo Avatar

    “a new government of Russia arose it was treated as if it was a continuation of the USSR”

    russia more or less insisted on that… among other things, it inherited the USSR’s position on the UN security council (which by your logic should absolutely not have happened).

    And… in the case of Italy, Germany and Japan (most recent examples) they all recanted their past and admitted to past sins etc russia didn’t do any of that (and still hasn’t and they’re still building statues to friggin’ Stalin).

    If it was important to treat russia like a blank slate russia should have acted like a blank slate.

    Your hatred of NATO is like col potter’s hatred of Trump – it takes up far too much space in your heart and mind.

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      I don’t understand the “as if it was” part. There’s nothing hypothetical about it. The same people remained in power. The oligarchs who received all of the formerly nationalized property were KGB employees. The current leader is a KGB employee. What is a continuation is not this? Russians still overwhelmingly believe that Stalin was the greatest leader in their history. Russia still funds all of the socialist leaders and parties around the world through the same Cold War channels. The Cuban regime exists only thanks to the material support from Russia. The entirety of Russian propaganda is unchanged from the Cold War era. The USSR is an object of cultish veneration, not only by retirees but by the younger generations as well, because this is what they were taught to believe. To conclude from all of this that Russia does not consider itself a continuation of the USSR, when Putin himself keeps saying that they are a continuation of the USSR, is a strange pastime, the purpose of which I cannot grasp.

      Like

    2. Col. Potter Avatar
      Col. Potter

      It does not take nearly enough space in my heart and mind. Thanks for the shout-out, though.

      Like

  6.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Yea no I have had enough. My original comment was to explain why I had down-voted Dreidel’s comment which has always been my policy. That being that I refuse to down-vote someone without explaining to them exactly why I did so.

    My follow up comments were to flesh out my perspective and to set the record straight instead of letting someone put words in my mouth.

    At this point I have stated what I believe and that is my opinion just as everyone else is entitled to their own opinions. All that to say at this point I don’t think there is any more point in continuing this argument. As it is not for the salvation of souls it is not worth more effort that I have already put into it. No one here is going to change their minds at this moment of time.

    • – W

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      Everything I listed is a fact of objective reality. Just like your sex is not a matter of opinion, neither are the facts listed. We need to live in reality and not imagine that everything is subjective and everybody should be free “to live their own truth.”

      Like

Leave a Reply