In Whittaker Chambers’s book The Witness, I reached the part that describes the questioning to which the Soviet spy Alger Hiss and his accuser, Whittaker Chambers, were subjected. It’s the most bizarre thing imaginable. The inquiry drowned in utter trivialities of who had what color hair, who paid what sum for some ancient clunker of a car, and who remembered some silly gossip from a decade earlier. The efforts to give every drop of every benefit of doubt to absolutely everybody made it impossible to do anything about the actual issue of Soviet spies in the U.S. government.

In the USSR, the spy, the spy’s accuser, their family members, and a bunch of random strangers would all be shot to death, and the whole matter would be solved within days.

Both methods are ridiculous, but it’s always one or the other. Nobody has come up with a version that would lie in the middle and avoid both the complete efficiency of the totalitarian disregard for the truth and the bumbling ineptitude of prissy veneration of everybody’s feelings.

Leave a Reply