Ben Shapiro wrote the script for “Confession” and got some well-known actors to star in the movie. I have read and watched more about the atrocities of Stalinism than a platoon of regular people can possibly need. I have no desire to know anything else about Stalinism, but I want to support right-wing art, so I watched the movie.

There is a bit of a boom in USSR-worship among young people. It’s considered cool to talk it up among the under-25 crowd. These are overwhelmingly the children of immigrants who had been financed by the USSR in their home countries. They retain a nice memory of the financing and pass it down the generational line. Courses on Stalinism are very rarely taught in American universities, which means that there is no widely accessible source of information about it.

Every semester, I stand in front of a new group of students and ask them, “What is the USSR? What do you know about it? Have you heard about Stalinism?” The answers are always “no, no, and no.”

To me, everything in “Confession” was familiar. I’m clearly not the intended audience, but there absolutely is an audience that desperately needs this movie. Shapiro’s writing is very honest, and he even breaks the taboo on discussing  the leading role of Jewish communists in the Ukrainian organized famine. I have ancestors on both sides, Jewish communists and Ukrainian peasants in the region most tragically affected by Holodomor. I can say that Shapiro is definitely very gutsy in writing this scene the way he did.

There are a few brilliant lines in the movie that give a lot to think about. One is, for example, “The state is the emanation of the people.” I’m quoting from memory, so it might be slightly different, but the idea is deep.

There has been a lot written about Stalinism. There are a million dramatic, powerful stories that could have fed Hollywood for a century, but nobody bothered to bring these stories to film. As a result, there is no reason why the USSR won’t be repeated. Nobody remembers what it was. Nobody even tried to condemn it. I’m very impressed that Ben Shapiro wanted to invest money into this project, but I’m not sure that there is going to be an audience.

Leave a Reply