I was asked in the Q&A to comment about Oswaldo Zavala. The reader finds his book to be hard to read and uninteresting and wonders whether the intended audience is academic.

I agree that the writing is poor, but I wouldn’t say that I find Zavala to be academically interesting. What he writes is pure propaganda of a rather plodding kind. His thinking is one-dimensional and quite boring. I’m very capable of reading books that are ideologically alien to me, as evidenced, for example, by my profound interest in Gerald Martin’s biography of Mario Vargas Llosa. But Oswaldo Zavala brings nothing but primitive sloganeering and can’t even couch it in interesting terms.

Leave a Reply