There are many very insane people, so I can’t say for sure that the following is a completely baseless battle with a straw man:
So this is what is going on. People mistakenly think the MLA convention is a major source of revenue for the association. They actually think the MLA organizes the job search process in such a way as to profit from the misery of jobseekers. At an extreme, they think the MLA is not just a clearinghouse for academic jobs and interviews but some kind of regulatory agency that sets the terms for the number of jobs and interviews available. At an even more extreme extreme (and this takes us back to a certain angry-pseudonymous Chronicle commenter), they believe that the MLA is in possession of information about interviews that, if released, would lead to a radical democratization of the job system whereby everybody in departments in the modern languages would spontaneously agree to interview candidates from low- and middle-ranked institutions in proportion to their numbers in the applicant pool. Relatedly, some people argue that the entire job system should be run by lottery.
What do you think? Do these completely deranged “people” that Michael Bérubé is talking about exist? Is there a significant number of them? Or is this a way of distracting all of us from real grievances against the MLA?
Is he sincere in the rest of this comment? Because there are only two possibilities: he is either insincere or a heavy drinker. People who decide to hold the MLA on the frakking Nob Hill of San Francisco and then ask why grad students who attend are unhappy cannot possibly be anything but these two things.
And the same goes for people who pretend that technological progress hasn’t happened. “Here is a boring and long-winded explanation of why we invented the MLA job interviews long before Skype became widely available.” I’m shocked he thought of publishing his comments on Facebook if he is such a stickler for communicating with people in person and not over the Internet.
I don’t know. I want to like this guy (because who else is there to defend the Modern Languages?) but it isn’t working out for me a whole lot.



