The University of Michigan will remove the grades that students receive in their freshman year from the transcripts and the GPA. The stated goal of this exercise is “to curb the mental health crisis unfolding among college-aged individuals.”
We keep hearing that mental illness is just like physical illness. But the proponents of this theory clearly don’t believe it themselves. They like to compare what they call mental illness to diabetes. Nobody suggests, however, that hiding my blood sugar readings from me will help alleviate my illness. To the contrary, if I don’t know what my readings are and if I don’t track them carefully on a daily basis, the illness will get worse. It’s only if I know exactly what is happening and share this information with my doctor that I will be able to control my condition. Eating 3 slices of chocolate cake and then pretending that my blood sugar reading is fantastic is not going to cure me. To the contrary, it will end up killing me.
Whatever people mean by this “unfolding mental health crisis”, the idea that hiding from reality will help people feel better about their lives makes no sense. People who are actually healthy in their minds like their lives, even when their grades are not great or when they have diabetes. Mental health is the capacity to accept what is. If you find the idea that you failed calculus devastating, that is not mental health. If you can’t look at your transcript without falling apart, that is anything but healthy.
University of Michigan does not allow students to opt in or out of this initiative. This will be imposed on everybody because if only some people opt in, they will stand out by virtue of not having freshman-year grades. This will “inadvertently become equated with them not doing well in class”, as the explanation provided by the university states. Of course, the reality is that these students are not doing well in class, indeed.
It is disappointing that mental health is now equated with being delusional about yourself and presenting a fake persona to others. This is a university that teaches very young people who are still in their teen years that this is a good life strategy.




