Somebody asked me why I’m learning German if you can use AI or a digital interpreter app to talk “to anybody in any language.”
Here’s the thing, though. I’ve had people stick their phones into my face to try to talk through an interpreter app. When that happened, I immediately lost all interest in talking to them about anything. It’s tiresome, it’s yet another screen, it’s all constantly interrupted because you need to press this or that. The frisson of excitement that wow, I actually managed to have a conversation with an actual German, is gone. With the app, you can possibly get directions while traveling but you aren’t making any friends, let alone improving your intellectual capacity.
I don’t want a hundred superficial, stilted app exchanges in German. I want to become a German speaker. I want to grow a whole part of my personality that thinks, dreams and expresses itself in German. It’s extremely hard but it’s such an amazing adventure. It’s like what we talked about before. I don’t want an app to live my life for me. I like my life. I don’t mind that things get hard. It’s good to overcome. It’s good to confront hardship. And it’s really good to feel that for the first time you are managing to establish a real connection with another person in a new language.
The excuse for the apps is that “you can save so much time.” But to do what? Save time on exercising your brain, forming new neural pathways, having fun… to what end? What would I be doing instead if I weren’t living my life?
Happy Palm Sunday or Easter, and let’s remain human.



