Technology as Nature asks an important question:
Why are all the liberals coming out of the woodwork
to insist that the Islamic-inspired terror attack in Paris has nothing at all to do with Islam?
I have an answer to this because this is something we definitely need to discuss.
The Koran is a book. A work of literature. What makes my entire profession as a literary critic possible is this interesting quality works of literature possess: they allow for as many (and more) readings as there are people on this planet. And all these readings have a right to exist. They don’t all have the right to get a passing grade in my courses but that’s a different matter.
The Koran only says what I want it to say. If I want to read the Koran (the Bible, Don Quixote, the menu I’ve been given at the local diner, etc) as saying that I need to stand on my head, say coocooricoo ten times and wave an orange flag in the process, who’s to stop me?
Islam, Christianity, Buddhism, the scholarly interpretation of War and Peace, etc. exist in a bizillion and one variations. Give me 10 minutes, and I will scare up 5 Christians right on the spot who assign a completely different meaning to any chosen verse from the Bible. Of course, they will all be totally wrong because the correct reading is mine but their readings will still exist.
When Spaniards went to slaughter the indigenous peoples of the Americas, they were waving Bibles throughout the entire process. But the Bibles didn’t make them slaughter children and rip out fetuses from women’s bellies and throw them to the dogs. The Bible was just an excuse. I read the Bible and it didn’t make me want to slaughter anybody. I also read the Koran and it didn’t make me a terrorist.
The problem doesn’t reside in books. It resides in the incapacity of many people to accept that their holy books are only holy to them and that it is fine. But if books – not just these books, any books at all – didn’t exist, there would still be crowds of people who would find it hard to accept the truly radical idea that what is super important to me might seem stupid, insignificant, and ridiculous to somebody else.
The greatest step forward we can all take in our development as human beings is to understand that nobody else is me. And that’s OK. The most horrible things human beings inflict on each other stem from their incapacity to see where they end and other people begin. Abusive parents lash out at their children when the children fail to perform as the perfect mirrors of the parents’ fantasies. Rapists invade the bodies of other human beings because they can’t accept those beings’ agency. Immigrants are marginalized when they can’t blend in completely and become the mirror image of the locals. Cartoonists are gunned down when their sense of humor differs from that of somebody else.
The reason why it is so damn hard to accept that other people are not a part of me is because this idea leads directly towards a great existential loneliness and confers an enormous responsibility to become worthy of the word “individual.” And that’s such an incredible drag. Who wants to do all that when there is an easy alternative to grab some ancient tome and go bash some folks in the head with it to convince them that they are an extension of me?