Quite a few Hispanic Hispanists are stuck in the rut of endlessly and sanctimoniously reminding the non-Hispanic Hispanists that we don’t have personal experience of what we are researching. Of course, if we make personal experience a requirement for a scholarly career, then Medievalists and Shakespearean scholars should all just go jump off a cliff.
What such people don’t understand is that there is no compliment greater than dedicating one’s one and only life to studying, teaching, and promoting their culture. Latin America is gaining prominence and even – maybe, possibly, almost – clout, but Spain is a small, comparatively poor country that is about to fall apart into tiny little pieces. We should treasure every bit of evidence that it is still relevant to people. And if those people were not born in Spain, that’s a good sign.
Seriously, if all you can offer the field is having been born somewhere, then that’s not a whole lot. We all experienced being born and growing up, so big whoop. A new reader of this blog is a historian who specializes in Soviet history. Would I ever suggest that his research is garbage because he isn’t from the USSR? Of course not because I’m not insane. Quite the opposite, I’m thrilled that he is doing the important work of filling in lacunae in the knowledge about my country. Why would I want to get into a pissing contest with a person like that?
P.S. I’m noticing that among Spanish Hispanists this is a habit of people in their 50s and 60s. Among Latin American Hispanists, however, this is very common in the 30-40-year-old range. That’s just a personal statistic, though.




