You know what really, really gets to me?
If I were to share with you, my readers, something like, “I have this persistent cough that just wouldn’t go away. I feel like my chest is constricted and I wake up at night drenched in cold sweat.” What would your advice be?
I’m guessing that any person in their right mind would say, “Go see a doctor!” I’m also guessing that nobody would start diagnosing me over the Internet and telling me how to cure this ailment sight unseen.
If I told you about a dysfunction in any system of organs in my body, the advice would be the same: talk to a specialist. Several years ago, for instance, I complained of a chest pain on the blog, and a reader who happened to be a nurse told me in no uncertain terms that I had to go to the ER. And this turned out to be amazing advice: I had pericarditis and needed to be treated. But even that reader – an actual medical professional – was not presuming to prescribe treatment for me online. I think we can all agree this is the right approach.
There is, however, one area in our bodies where every Tom, Dick and Henrietta thinks it’s OK to diagnose and prescribe treatment left and right. Here is an example for you. A person asks:
Other than a recent, brief and dissatisfying encounter, my SO and I haven’t had sex in a very long time. At the beginning of our relationship, we were very sexually active but my desire over the course of the last few years has completely tanked. I still very much love and am attracted to my SO, but I worry about our future. How do I regain my mojo and how do I know if this is a sign that our relationship is reaching the end?
Obviously, nobody but a specialist can even decipher what “I’m attracted but don’t feel desire” means. All anybody can do is gently suggest that this person take this query to a sexologist. Sadly, there are many other people who would benefit from seeing such a specialist, too. And it is those people precisely who are interested in projecting their own deeply Victorian views on others. Here is an example:
Many of us have these romantic visions of what our sex lives are supposed to be like: spontaneous, plentiful, void of drama or misunderstandings, and perfectly matched in libido to our partner(s). That just ain’t reality, especially for the long haul.
Translation: “My sex is infrequent, routine, filled with misunderstandings, and always leaves either me or my partner unsatisfied. That’s my reality and the price I pay for the all-important privilege of being in a long-term relationship, and don’t anybody dare suggest life can be different.”
From the viewpoint informed by her own dysfunction, this dispenser of advice exhorts the poor reader to “keep trying” in a way that reminded me of “close your eyes and think of England.”
What really gets me is that people who identify as feminists keep offering this extremely outdated kind of advice. Years ago, I wrote about another feminist who blithely dispensed sex advice of the most offensively patriarchal and anti-woman kind anybody can imagine. It seems like there is now a re-incarnation of that woman-hating sex specialist. (Or is it the same person? I don’t want to believe there could be two of them prowling the world, dispensing their sexual wisdom.)
Thank you, dear Cliff Arroyo, for this great link. And just out of curiosity, how is it possible for a blog that has exactly 2 posts to have 296 followers? If somebody tells me this blogger is a bot, that will be a relief.