First of all, let me say that we are all intelligent, reasonably well-educated people on this blog, and I’m sure nobody here shares Ian Welsh’s extreme ignorance in believing that until recently, Ukraine has been part of Russia. Even within the USSR, Ukraine was a republic with equal rights within the union of 15 separate republics. The Ukrainian Socialist Soviet Republic had an anthem and a national flag of its own and was not considered part of Russia by anybody.
Some people are asking why Ukraine should resist becoming part of the Russian Federation today. Russia is much richer, it has oil and gas, and Ukraine’s constant problems with paying to heat and feed itself would be solved.
The problem, however, is that there is, among vast numbers of the Russian people, a deep-seated and completely interiorized xenophobic contempt for Ukrainians. Any Ukrainian will tell you that engaging with Russians in any capacity is not a pleasing experience. There are constant nasty jokes, degrading comments, offensive remarks. If you are gay, transgender, black, Native American, or Jewish, I’m sure you have had this kind of experience.
To give just one among literally hundreds of examples I could adduce, I will tell you about a conversation I once had with N. in the early stages of our relationship. We were having a discussion about the value of higher education when he said, “Well, this is a difference between your provincial worldview and my metropolitan one.”
“I’m sorry, what?” I said. “I lived my entire life in the second largest city in my country. It is a huge industrial and cultural center with a population of 1,5 million people. You come from a tiny town with the population of $35,ooo. How does it follow from this that I’m provincial and you are metropolitan?”
“Well, Ukraine is located on the outskirts,” N. shared cheerfully.
“The outskirts of what?” I asked.
He couldn’t answer, so I grew very agitated and erupted in a long lecture about colonial mentality.
Mind you, this was a conversation between a highly-educated, very well-read man who deeply loved a woman and wanted to make a good impression on her. It simply never occurred to him that there might be anything wrong with this vision of Ukrainians. This was just a fact that he was relating with no desire to wound.
Would it be reasonable for Ukrainians to want to be part of a country where they are despised as a matter of course?
P.S. For those who know Russian, here is a beautiful post on this subject from my favorite blogger, an 89-year-old representative of the true Russian intelligentsia.