No Voice

I’m being interviewed for a Ukrainian magazine about my book. The interviewer sent a list of questions and I’m trying to answer them. And God, it’s hard. I’ve lucked out with an interviewer who is a writer published in two dozen languages and a very profound person. She read the book carefully and probably twice, judging by the depth of the understanding of what I say in it. So the questions aren’t the problem. I am.

I discovered that I don’t have a voice in Ukrainian. I developed as a person and an intellectual in English-speaking countries. When I try to answer questions in Ukrainian, I revert to who I was at 22 when I left. And I wasn’t anything special back then. I was very immature and not deeply interesting. In the book, I mostly managed to avoid sounding like a kid, especially in the parts about the nation-state and neoliberalism. But when I talk to an actual person, even in writing, I revert to childishness, and it feels weird.

I’ll probably also have another interview in person, and I need to figure this out before I scare people off with this personal drama.

9 responses to “No Voice”

  1. cliff arroyo Avatar

    ”Β need to figure this out before I scare people offΒ ”

    You’re an educator so maybe working up some mini-lectures on the main topics would help. Pretend you’re teaching to a Ukrainian speaking group and work out how you would do 5 or 10 minutes on the nation state, 5 or ten minutes on neoliberalism or wokeness….

    Pretend you’re arguing with a fellow scholar who doesn’t belief neoliberalism exists, what would you say?

    Like

  2. random reader Avatar
    random reader

    Can you write your answers in English and translate once done?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. cliff arroyo Avatar

      “Can you write your answers in English and translateΒ ”

      That could work maybe for some people…. but there’s a ‘translated from English’ register in lots of European languages that sounds…. awful. I can detect it in Polish and Spanish and German and it’s an immediate turn off……

      Like

    2. Clarissa Avatar

      I can do that, of course, but this interview isn’t my end goal. If I want to be a public intellectual in Ukraine, I need to be able to speak like the serious person that I am.

      Like

  3. Post Alley Crackpot Avatar
    Post Alley Crackpot

    Or you could just lean into being a product of a diaspora and do your interviews in multiple languages …

    You’re probably far from being alone in this regard.

    So … my first language was Dutch, my second was Turkish … and I’d started to forget what bits I knew starting at age 5.

    English has a funny way of crowding out other languages.

    When I’m in the Netherlands or Turkey, I know what many of the signs say, I even pick up on bits of conversation, but to actually speak?

    At least I won’t wind up in the wrong set of toilets. :-)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. methylethyl Avatar

      I think my Dad had Turkish as his 2nd and Dutch 5th– I wonder how common that combo is?

      Like

      1. cliff arroyo Avatar

        “Turkish … and Dutch I wonder how common that combo is?”

        There are hundreds of thousands of Turks in both the Netherlands and Belgium, so…. not that weird.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. methylethyl Avatar

          Ah, so not uncommon– Dad just approached things in his usual sideways fashion. Learned Turkish in Istanbul and Dutch in Vietnam πŸ˜‰

          Like

  4. donbenham Avatar
    donbenham

    Ask the interviewer what she suggests to improve your Ukrainian intellectual voice…..

    Like

Leave a comment