I’m fascinated by Sarma Melngailis’s memoir (the one with the abortion story I quoted yesterday). It’s identical to the novels of neoliberal femininity that I discuss in my new book. Their heroines can have every economic advantage, fantastic careers, connections, achievements, riches – and they’ll throw it all away to pursue the dream of being enslaved by a low-quality dude. They all either reject the possibility of having children or dump the children they already have in order to be free to get bossed around and humiliated by some random guy. And not by some very manly, alpha type but a hyena-like degraded loser. I’m not talking Shades of Gray. This isn’t women prostituting themselves in inventive ways. That wouldn’t be an interesting development because that always existed.
I’ve been observing this phenomenon for as long as I have been a literary critic. There’s no medieval or Victorian heroine that would dream of being as slavishly and abjectly subservient to a man as the modern liberated woman. And look at Melngailis who is not writing fiction but narrating her life. It’s still the exact same thing. Total self-abasement for some utterly worthless dude. Or a bunch of dudes. In these stories, a successful, serious man who offers respect, equality and parity gets rejected in favor of some antisocial, emasculated loser gigolo. Melngailis discarded a wonderful husband who gave her everything to pursue feminized (in her own description), much younger men who sucked her dry and spat her out.
Nobody is talking about this because we are stuck on the idea that female liberation in real life should result in literature that celebrates said liberation. But what actually exists in accounts of women’s lives (be they fictional or not) is a wasteland of such horror that no 19th-century female character upset with the expectations of being the Angel in the House could even imagine.
Melngailis is completely liberated of all societal expectations. Highly successful in very masculine jobs (she worked for Bear Stearns and Bain Capital and made a packet, then founded a successful restaurant in NYC). Not burdened by family and children. Free from any form of morality. Sexually promiscuous with zero societal stigma. The dream has been fulfilled! Yet read her memoir and you’ll see what abject misery this dream brought her. This isn’t my interpretation. Melngailis doesn’t claim that how her life unfolded is anything short of catastrophic.