Sign up for a free recipe e-book →

Clarissa's Blog

Should the US Bomb Iran?

Published by

Clarissa

on

Obviously, I hate the Iranian regime. And I feel terrible for the protesters. And, as I said before, I know very little about the country.

So the reason why I think it’s a stupid idea for the US to bomb Iran might not be my most brilliant one. But I do think it’s valid, which is why I’ll express it.

Iranians are going to hate us for it. Every time we bomb somebody not of our civilization* to bring them freedom, they end up hating us. Even if they proceed to enjoy the freedom. Why do we need to antagonize Iranians “for their own benefit”? Let them figure it out. Absolutely any engagement will lead to them hating us and pouting for the next three million years.

In the spirit of full disclosure, I’m also very tired with the obsessive concentration on foreign policy when domestic issues are unsolved. I live here. I want things to get better here. That’s my #1 issue.

Input is welcome but I beg people to abstain from drawing parallels between Venezuela and Iran because that just makes me very sad.

*Example of somebody of our civilization who did manage to not hate us for bombing them is Germany.

5 responses to “Should the US Bomb Iran?”

  1. Avatar
    Anonymous

    The short answer is no. The long answer boils down to no, but its a lot more nuanced.

    First off, we have no declaration of war. It was unlawful for Obama to do drone strikes, and it is unlawful for Trump to do bombings. Quick retaliations are allowed as shown under the President being allowed to deploy the military without a declaration of war by congress for up to 90 days. This is not a retaliation, this would be a first strike.

    Secondly, and I will try not to draw parallels to Venezuela, but the difference between Germany/Japan and the various Middle Eastern Nations we bombed is a mix of the aftermath, and the culture. Both Germany and Japan had very similar to Western at the time Cultures. So we weren’t also trying to force their people to change culture. Second there was an immediate threat to both that lasted for decades, long enough for the surviving population to be replaced with a population that didn’t experience the bombings. Here there is no such thing. We bomb them, and afterwards without an external threat that is not us, we become the target of their anger from the violation of their sovereignty, and the bombing of their lands.

    Think of it this way. We might despise the leftist and think what they are doing is horrible, but if another nation came in and kidnapped Gavin Newsome or blew up a BLM headquarters, we would be furious. Sure our enemies were removed from the board, but it wasn’t nation X’s right to do so. They violated our national sovereignty and nation X would be hated by the leftists and the center and the right would likely never trust them again in their lifetimes.

    Third this sets an extremely bad precedent. A basic law of nature is don’t do to others what you would not want done to you. Also known as what goes around comes around. If our government keeps blatantly and openly interfering in the affairs of other nations. And I am not talking about the tariffs, blockades, or refusing entry those are all standard actions taken by any form of government. I am talking about openly hostile actions, bombing, kidnapping, seizing ships, etc. Then it opens us up to other nations willing to do the same. At the same time, nations who are generally our allies are less and less likely to support us if push comes to shove.

    Lastly you are entirely correct that he really should be focus on domestic issues. He was elected to seal the border, send back the illegals, and break the corruption in DC. He was not elected to invade, bomb, etc other nations no matter how evil their governments are. Because and I cannot stress this point enough. We are not at war with them.

    I am really not happy with Trump right now. Although I suppose I should not be surprised. Between Israel burning all their political power, favors, etc. in pursuit of their Greater Israel Project, and our Government needing massive distractions from our current problems. And lastly the 10 Kingdoms being divied up for the reign of the Antichrist, well I can see how all this is occurring now of all times.

    • – W

    Like

    Reply
    1. Clarissa Avatar
      Clarissa

      Thank you for this thoughtful response. I appreciate it. The only thing to which I take exception is the “treat others” part.

      I respond to it in a separate post.

      Like

      Reply
  2. Stringer Bell Avatar
    Stringer Bell

    So many reasons to oppose and not a single one to support, other than this vague notion of freedom which is so laughable I won’t even bother engaging with it.

    • The 1979 revolution succeeded because it was driven by a clear ideology of Islamism and anti-Westernism. Right or wrong, doesn’t matter. What matters is they were protesting *for* something, rather than against something. The current protests have no such ideology.
    • There’s no credible opposition leader who inspires confidence in the people. A bunch of young people protests (half of them Mossad plants lol) will somehow dislodge a deeply entrenched government in a couple of weeks?
    • Once again, no vision for the future.
    • Clown thinking to assume a country with 3000 years of absolute monarchy to suddenly transition into a western democracy, and that people in Iran are yearning for it. You have to be either stupid or evil to believe this.
    • Regime change cannot be achieved through limited strikes, dropping Starlink, or cyberattacks. A true overthrow would require a conventional war. The jews would love nothing more, but does the US have the stomach for this?
    • Regimes can limp on forever, even in poverty (see North Korea, Cuba). As long as the state can remain powerful, it can persist for a long time.
    • No positive test-case for a successful regime change in the region. Iraq, Libya, Syria, and Egypt have all led to more misery and instability.

    Like

    Reply
    1. Clarissa Avatar
      Clarissa

      Thank you, SB, for the list. I don’t know or understand the region, so this perspective helps. My instinct is that we shouldn’t get involved because the US has been involved in the Middle East for decades and the results are always terrible. This is not our civilization. We clearly don’t understand these people. Maybe we should let them be.

      The point about there being no vision for the future is well-taken.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply
  3. Stringer Bell Avatar
    Stringer Bell

    This is why jews (officially) took over CBS news. It took US four years to calculate the 3000 deaths on 9/11. But Bari Weiss made a couple of phone calls and confirmed 20000 deaths in two days. Jesus christ, what parasites these people are.

    Like

    Reply

Leave a comment

A conservative literary critic and college professor

Recent posts