Those Who Lost

One of Rafael Chirbes’s greatest intellectual concerns was the suffering of Germans at the hands of the Allies in the closing years of World War II. I learned from him about the vast amount of literature, including memoirs and fiction, on this subject. I’m not entirely sure why this was of so much interest to him. Did he identify with the Germans because his own side, the Republicans, were the losers in the Spanish Civil War that they brought about?

I am not aware of any other non-German, Western intellectual who would be as profoundly devastated by the suffering of the Germans in World War II. Even if the issue is mentioned in passing, it never is articulated as the foundation of anybody’s worldview. Curiosly, Chirbes, whose French was at the near-native level, but whose German was rudimentary, read and thought very little about the suffering of the French during World War II. He loved French literature, of course, and read an enormous amount in the language, staying current on all of the recent award winners and bestsellers in France. But the writer’s interest in the devastation of World War II was mostly concentrated on Germany.

2 responses to “Those Who Lost”

  1. PaulS Avatar
    PaulS

    In SA, it was the failure to acknowledge the suffering of Germans after WW1 that was considered to be the root of the problem.

    https://irr.org.za/media/punishment-and-prescience-at-versailles-politicsweb

    Like

  2.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    “But the writer’s interest in the devastation of World War II was mostly concentrated on Germany.”

    Thats probably because most of he devastation of WW2 was concentrated on the German people. I’ve mentioned David Irving before, his book on the Destruction of Dresden lays that out perfectly, this was a war of extinction. If you don’t know about the Eisenhower camps, see Other Losses, or the mass rape of German women by Russian soldiers or the kangaroo trials at Nuremberg, see Freda Utleys The High Cost of Vengeance, or the Morgenthau plan, than you don’t know what this war was really about. The French, who started WW2 along with the British, did suffer in the war but it was almost entirely due to Allied bombing. It’s almost as if the Allies had to make up the Holocaust just to justify their own mass atrocities.

    Walnut

    Like

Leave a comment

A conservative literary critic and college professor