Why did people dislike my post about the parent-teacher meeting? Is it because of the joke about my mother’s death? We’re Ukrainians. We use a lot of dark humor to deal with trauma. If you heard the massively popular comedy routines about the war that are done by stand-up comedians in Ukraine today, you would probably keel over.

I thought ever since Camus mocked the idea that there was one correct way to mourn the death of your mother, people got over it. But apparently not. For people who want to be judgmental, I talked to my mother (and I don’t mean briefly, I mean very long conversations) at least once but often twice a day, every single day since my father died in 2022. Every single bloody day, I listened to her weep for up to an hour and tell me how her life has no meaning and everything, including me, is horrible. What have you done for yours, Mr. and Mrs. Judgmental?

48 responses to “The Downvote Mystery”

  1. Col. Potter Avatar
    Col. Potter

    Well, I was going to go into a much-too-long explanation of my own downvote, but the simple version is, I didn’t see a joke. I thought I read a (proud?) recalling of some… behavior I don’t agree with?

    And for what it’s worth, I do offer my condolences–been an orphan myself now for a little over a year. “It gets easier” is too glib and surface–when it is not easy, I hope you’re surrounded by support and love.

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      There is definitely a curious contradiction between being welcoming to immigration and not being able to tolerate the mildest and most insignificant of cultural differences.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Col. Potter Avatar
        Col. Potter

        ….Huh?

        Like

        1. cliff arroyo Avatar

          “thought I read a (proud?) recalling of some… behavior I don’t agree with?”

          A cultural difference that you didn’t recognize. Considering that our hostess is from a European culture and incredibly well assimilated…. consider the potential for misunderstandings and conflicts with people from much more alien cultures who have little intention of either assimilating or letting their children assimilate.

          Like

          1. Clarissa Avatar

            That’s exactly my point. If I’m too exotic, then you’re most definitely not ready for what the real différence looks like. Because I’m really not that exotic.

            Like

            1. Col. Potter Avatar
              Col. Potter

              Very interesting. I guess I would then say that a “misunderstanding” is, by its nature, not such a big deal. I don’t think you’ve established a convincing connection between a simple downvote (as in, I didn’t care for this) and “not being able to tolerate” mild cultural differences… I mean, I don’t care for asparagus either, but I can tolerate it just fine if it’s put in front of me.

              The more interesting part to me is that I actually more or less got Cliff’s joke–and Cliff is not someone I have ever associated with anything resembling humor. Not ever. Not for the most fleeting faction of a moment. But in his “needs more than one arm” joke, I saw something of a comic sensibility. Whereas in the original post, I failed to see it, even though I… occasionally associate Clarissa’s posts with humor and evidence of the use of humorous rhetoric.

              So… all that means I think you’re too exotic? Or was that also humor?

              And finally, is Cliff actually N?

              Like

              1. Pen Avatar
                Pen

                Cliff is not N. I’ve been here since…2010 or 2011 and I can can confirm that.

                Like

              2. Clarissa Avatar

                Wait, who thinks that Cliff is N? I completely missed that particular conspiracy theory.

                My husband doesn’t read the blog at all. It would be cruel of him to read it and rob me of the opportunity to tell him all of these stories in person.

                Thank you for being such a long-time reader. I really appreciate it.

                Like

              3. Clarissa Avatar

                Left the app and went to the actual website and realized that, once again, WordPress is not showing me all of the comments. If it weren’t for Pen, I would have missed this fascinating development.

                Like

              4. Col. Potter Avatar
                Col. Potter

                “Wait, who thinks that Cliff is N?”

                Yes, that would be me. I mean, I was being… semi-serious.

                It just hit me all at once: Cliff’s general humorlessness, his imperious attitudes as he demands information (as opposed to say, asking questions) as if he were dictating his posts from a throne, and the loving, even romantic, way he swooped into the thread to explain how funny your joke actually was, how beautifully you had assimilated, etc. And I thought: oh my goodness, he must be N! Because what a perfect husband he’d be for Clarissa, and, well, he’s acting like a husband.

                I was, of course, 100% wrong. I’d be more than 100% wrong if that were possible. But, I was also… I’d say, 54% kidding.

                Liked by 1 person

              5. Clarissa Avatar

                I’m sad that Cliff doesn’t live close to where I do because we could be great friends. He understands food and Eastern European politics. Hanging out together would be so much fun. But he can’t be my husband because he’s extremely verbal. Imagine two such very verbal people as a couple. That would not be pretty. My husband doesn’t say or write as many words in a month as Cliff does just here on the blog. And when he does say something, which is infrequent, it’s never what I expect. He is a walking stereotype of a grim, silent, brooding Russian, and I am a walking stereotype of an excitable, gregarious, intense Ukrainian. When we tell people that he’s Russian and I’m Ukrainian, everybody laughs. People ask us if we do this on purpose because we’re like a walking stereotype. “After observing you and N, I finally understand why your two countries are at war,” an acquaintance said, “You guys are just so different.”

                Like

              6. Col. Potter Avatar
                Col. Potter

                “I’m sad that Cliff doesn’t live close…”

                The story about you and N illustrating the Russian-Ukraine war is funny–and kind of sweet (if we set aside the realities of war for a moment, of course).

                My wife and I used to enjoy watching Sex and the City together, and there was an occasionally successful story arc involving the main character Carrie with a Russian artist played by Mikhail Baryshnikov. Carrie’s friend is diagnosed with breast cancer and starts undergoing treatment. Baryshnikov’s character responds with example after example of friends of his who had cancer and died, which appalls Carrie to no end. And for a few very funny minutes, they both reach an impasse because neither can understand why the other is responding that way.

                Like

              7. Clarissa Avatar

                By the way, Sex and the City blighted N’s personal life for a long time because the idea that that was a realistic representation of women made him terrified of women. I had to have many conversations with him, explaining that that stuff is not real.

                Like

  2. cliff arroyo Avatar

    “the joke about my mother’s death?”

    Hey, I tried… I even contributed my own dark joke…. maybe it was too subtle?

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      You definitely understand Eastern Europeans. 😆😆

      Like

  3. P Avatar
    P

    I felt bad for the teacher…

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      But not for the child who keeps getting Bs for readng, in spite of reading an enormous lot? Imagine how it must feel at that age to see that no matter how much you read, your grade does not reflect that.

      Like

      1. PaulS Avatar
        PaulS

        Who cares about reading. In SA parents get into brawls about high school rugby.

        Die_Revenant · r/rugbyunion

        Large brawl during a high school game in South Africa yesterday

        View on reddit

        Like

    2. Col. Potter Avatar
      Col. Potter

      “I felt bad for the teacher”

      RIGHT?? I mean, to get that emotional dump when you’re just trying to do your job?

      As for the child, you didn’t mention that Kiara consistently receives Bs in reading. A B+, in fact, is a terrific grade.

      Like

      1. Clarissa Avatar

        For a child who reads better than 100% of kids in the district and has a vocabulary no college Freshman I’ve ever met does?

        What’s with the tyranny of low expectations? I’m starting to feel a profound need to import a couple thousand high-achieving Indians into the area.

        Like

        1. Clarissa Avatar

          “I was just doing my job, Herr Offizier.”

          😆😆😆

          Next time, I’ll tag posts with the word “humor” because otherwise my jokes are clearly not landing.

          Like

    3. cliff arroyo Avatar

      “felt bad for the teacher…”

      Explaining humor… cause that always works….

      To understand it, it helps to have some info on parent teacher meetings in Eastern Europe (my description is about Poland* but I hear similar stories from throughout the region).

      For parents, everything about the school system was designed to reinforce the idea that they were incompetent boobs. The teacher was the expert who was expected to clean up the mess the parents had made and do what they could to course correct and the parents were supposed to sit meekly, listen and try to implement the teacher’s directions.

      Also, there is a general regional tendency to Accentuate the Negative. To put it in American terms, if a student has 4 A’s and one B the parent teacher meeting will focus on reasons for the substandard performance.

      The humor of the original post is about the indifference of bureaucracy to human events (and the humor of a tenured language professor justifying her parenting to a grade school teacher).

      Sorry about that…

      *things have changed a lot in recent years but there are still times where those involved revert to type

      Like

      1. Clarissa Avatar

        I sincerely thought that the objection to the post was my perceived disrespect for my dead mother. It could never occur to me that people would get sore on behalf of the teacher. It’s very weird to me. There is something in the collective psyche regarding teachers that I, as a lifelong teacher, don’t understand.

        People either don’t know or pretend not to know that a funny, goofy, completely laid-back parent like myself is a teacher’s dream. Parents get in the teachers’ faces over every percentage point on 7-year-olds’ report cards. They throw fits over any attempt to discipline the little darlings. They have to be begged not to do every project and assignment instead of the child. Last week, I was volunteering as a water lady at the charitable run at the school. When the pre-K group was running, one of the moms ran next to her kid, cheering him and pushing other preschoolers out of his way so that he could win.

        Like

        1. Clarissa Avatar

          Just one story to illustrate. When I was in Spain, I was, for some reason, included in an email chain of parents who were trying to get a new male teacher fired. It was something completely trivial that he said. I don’t even remember what, but the parents were on a rampage. And guess what? The young teacher was fired.

          People are very clueless about what it actually is like.

          Like

      2. Col. Potter Avatar
        Col. Potter

        “Explaining humor…”

        That was pretty helpful and clear… I guess I get it about 75% at this point, and I’m happy to take a C. Bureaucracy’s indifference to humanity has been good for a laugh for a pretty long while now (I’m a big fan of Gogol’s The Inspector General, although I’m sure it loses something in translation).

        “and the humor of a tenured language professor justifying her parenting to a grade school teacher…”

        That’s kind of a swing and a miss for me. Tenured-shmenured–prestige and acclaim as a professor doesn’t have a lot to do with whether or not you’re a good parent. (This is not to cast doubt on Clarissa’s parenting, which I’m sure is just fine. And a parent should be a constant supporter and cheerleader for their kid.)

        As for Eastern European culture and its humor, I suppose the closest I’ve gotten are the (translated) collections of Wise Men of Chelm jokes (funniest clean jokes in the world, as far as I’m concerned) as well as Nathan Ausubel’s A Treasury of Jewish Folklore–lots of jokes from and about the Old Country. Perhaps for me the ultimate joke of this ilk appears in a moment from Fiddler on the Roof–Tevye the milkman cries out to God, “Dear God, I’m so tired of pulling this cart!” After a moment, he nods slightly, and repositions himself so that he’s pushing the cart. That’s culture and philosophy in a joke.

        So I will reward the original joke with an almost silent chuckle.

        Like

        1. Clarissa Avatar

          Another funny thing that happened at the parent-teacher meeting is that the teacher said that we should pray together at the beginning of the meeting. I support that. It’s a Christian school, so we should definitely pray. But the way Protestants pray is very different from how the Orthodox do it. Protestants kind of ramble for a while with a text they design on the spot and adapt to existing circumstances. I find that very funny and kind of uncomfortable. My priest says that we should not give instructions to God about what to do for us because it’s hubris. We find our greatest joy in “Not my will, but yours be done”.

          So when she suggested that we pray, I automatically started with “Our Father who art in heaven.” And she automatically started with, “Dear God, we thank you for this wonderful opportunity…” And then we both kind of stared at each other in confusion.

          Like

          1. Col. Potter Avatar
            Col. Potter

            “Another funny thing…”

            Now that I get.

            Like

            1. Clarissa Avatar

              You know what it took me not to start goofing off when she opened with this HR-meeting-type prayer? I’m a paragon of self -control.

              Like

          2. cliff arroyo Avatar
            cliff arroyo

            “suggested that we pray”

            In the American protestant tradition that I’m familiar with that usually means “listen to me as I free associate and call it a prayer”. They might give you a chance to add something beyond an occasional “praise the lord!” but it doesn’t usually mean praying together.

            Like

            1. Clarissa Avatar

              Now I know. But imagine my feelings in the moment.

              I encountered something like this one once before, where we had a guy come to our church who wanted to convert to Orthodoxy from Protestantism. It was really funny because he thought that he was supposed to answer the priest’s rhetorical questions during the sermon and share his own opinions on the subject of the sermon. The priest looked very scandalized. I was almost weeping with laughter in the pew.

              Like

  4.  Avatar
    Anonymous
    1. You’ve said in the past that you don’t care about grades at this age, but now the difference between perfect and a B becomes important.
    2. Maybe a week earlier you had an, “I don’t care about your struggle, it ‘s the GPA that matters” post.

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      Should I spell the word “humor”? Because even after I explained that this is supposed to be funny, people are still pouting over the post.

      None of this is remotely important, but the total incapacity of having a quiet chuckle over something that is clearly humorous in intent is disturbing.

      Like

      1. Col. Potter Avatar
        Col. Potter

        “Should I spell the word ‘humor’?…”

        Dude… read the original post and all your responses–you are all over the place. And this is coming from someone who is frequently all over the place, so I know something whereof I speak.

        If we parse the original post and all of your responses, we can conclude…

        1. 1) You’re making a joke about parent-teacher conferences, and the kind of parent who vents about grades (or any perceived slights toward their kids).
        2. 2) You are shocked, shocked that we who misunderstood were not actually judging you for being irreverent about your mother. You were instead, as noted above, comically exaggerating the kind of parent that you are not. Because you are funny, goofy, and completely laid-back. And yet…
        3. 3) You are genuinely and seriously irked that your most excellent reader daughter is getting dinged on her grades on technicalities, while students who can’t perform as well wind up with higher grades.
        4. 4) On the other hand, you are not being serious in any of these posts about anything, including your daughter’s grades, because you’re being “clearly humorous in intent.”
        5. 5) Those of us who get confused are disturbing.

        It’s either a joke or it ain’t, Cookie.

        Like

        1. zinemin Avatar
          zinemin

          Humor is a way of expressing aggression here, but I don’t see the problem with that. It is annoying if a teacher punishes a child with a worse grade because she was with her dying grand-mother.
          As a teacher coming from a family of teachers I think a good teacher would want to know this important context and will apologize and change the grade.
          Yes grades are unimportant in the long run but they are a feedback to the child and in this case they were hurtful. I don’t think this will ruin the teacher’s day. I would change it, feel a bit sorry (for the child, not myself) and then forget about it because the next problem will certainly come up.
          Btw I suspect the reason you feel like teachers should be spared negative feelings (and children shouldn’t) might also be because you Americans feel guilty about paying your teachers too little. What about paying them better and treating them like adults?

          Like

          1. Col. Potter Avatar
            Col. Potter

            “Humor is a way…”

            Yes, you’re quite right. Ideally the teacher should change the grade, and definitely we should pay our teachers more (I teach too, though at the university level). It’s just the way Clarissa presented the (humorous?) story, the teacher was simply following protocol because of assignments, and it wasn’t clear that they already knew the reason Kiara wasn’t turning them in. (If the teacher DID already know, that changes the situation considerably.) But as told, the teacher was simply explaining policy and then getting hit with the big picture reality.

            And yes, solve the problem and move on, because the next problem will come up–we’ve all been there.

            Like

            1. Clarissa Avatar

              The teacher is trying to make the point that children are stuck with the consequences of their parents’ actions. This is a correct point, and I support her decision to make it. In response, I was making the point that adults should live with the consequences of their actions, which consequences I humorously inflicted on the teacher.

              As for aggression, I know that I absolutely do come off as significantly more aggressive than a median American woman. But hey, have you met Russians? When my husband orders food at a restaurant, I always feel like I have to hypercompensate by being extra smiley and chirpy because he comes off as massively pissed off, without remotely intending to.

              Like

          2. Clarissa Avatar

            It’s a myth that schoolteachers in the U.S. are underpaid. A public school teacher in Illinois, with comparable years of experience as mine, several degrees fewer, zero expectation of research and academics self governance, makes more than I do. They can retire at 54, get a second job on top of a very generous retirement and full benefits, and continue working for the next 30 years, getting what, in fact, is two salaries.

            Like

  5. cliff arroyo Avatar

    “Cliff’s general humorlessness”

    I take exception to that! I am an effin’ laugh riot!

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      You have a great sense of humor.

      Like

    2. Col. Potter Avatar
      Col. Potter

      It could well be, Cliff, that this is another example of cultural differences that I didn’t recognize.

      Reminds me of a story my dad used to like to tell about the time he and my Uncle Dick (my Mom’s brother–he introduced the two of them, somewhat to his regret) saw Les Vacances de Monsieur Hulot. Not a movie the two of them would have sought out, but I guess they found a theatre where it was playing and had some time to kill. And they thought it was the funniest damn thing they had ever seen.

      They enjoyed it so much that they eventually saw it a second time, and throughout, they looked at each other and said, “What the hell are we watching?”

      It’s hard to pin down humor. (I saw it myself some years back and got a kick out of it, although Annie Hall, Blazing Saddles, and Dr. Strangelove all make me laugh more.)

      Like

      1. cliff arroyo Avatar

        “Les Vacances de Monsieur Hulot“

        Saw it in an art theater many years ago and… didn’t get it. Very tied to time and place and hadn’t aged well.

        Modern European tourism has its own share of oddities but only the British Come Fly with Me really addresses it AFAIK.

        youtube is a very good source of humor, my current favorite is Husk IRL who interacts with AI (both audio only and also on video). Deadpan and hilarious.

        Like

        1. Clarissa Avatar

          Hey, what’s happening in Poland? I saw crazy footage on X.

          Like

          1. cliff arroyo Avatar

            “happening in Poland?”

            I’ll probably do a post tomorrow or so… a long simmering feud. Started and maintained by PiS which first tried to destroy the Constitutional Tribunal (and the constitution) and is now very hypocritically acting as its great” “defender”… a lot of it just stupid. I also wouldn’t be surprised if russian money were involved since PiS and its supporters hate Tusk far more than they hate russia.

            Like

            1. Clarissa Avatar

              Please do a post. I’m seeing very contradictory reports on social media. As always, it’s foreigners freaking out without much knowledge of the situation.

              Like

              1. cliff arroyo Avatar

                “seeing very contradictory reports on social media”

                This is very accurate, it leaves out some context here and there but the broad strokes are right.

                I should add that Kaczyński hates Tusk more than anything in the world and blames him, personally, for the Smolensk catastrophe (probably psychologically distancing himself from his own guilt in organizing the event that his brother was going to).

                And, again, Nawrocki has… ambitions of turning the ceremonial post of president into a policy-making position and everything he doesn’t and doesn’t do (like fulfilling his constitutional duties) is related to that.

                Anonymous (@YourAnonCentral) ·

                Tusk backed a judge’s order suspending Poland’s PiS-appointed tribunal chief over blocking elected judges. PiS party figures face mounting corruption cases and questions over Russian links, float talks of Poland exiting EU, a stated goal of the Kremlin. https://t.co/uwdmoSQVnU

                View on X

                Like

              2. Clarissa Avatar

                Thank you. This helps. How do you feel about Tusk? Is he good for the country? Overall, I have absolutely no opinion on the subject, and I will trust whatever you say.

                Like

  6. cliff arroyo Avatar

    “How do you feel about Tusk? Is he good for the country?”

    Short answer (might write more on the blog): Yes. He’s far from perfect but at heart he’s a nation stater who knows his way around both Brussels and the shark-filled Polish political scene and has gotten a lot for the country partly because he knows to do that while not antagonizing them. That’s one reason his enemies hate him. Polish politicians tend to live for pointless squabbling and picking unnecessary fights and can’t believe he’s gotten more by not starting fights….

    He doesn’t fit into the simple normy binary “nationalist” vs “globalist” and, as I said is far from perfect, but will probably be remembered as one of the great Polish politicians of the current interwar period.

    Like

    1. Clarissa Avatar

      That’s really great. I only know about this from social media but it looks like there is a big propaganda campaign against him. I’m guessing it’s funded by the Kremlin? It’s like a tsunami of hatred for Tusk suddenly erupted. It doesn’t look very organic.

      Like

Leave a Reply