Liberalism unavoidably leads to totalitarianism.

This sounds paradoxical because why should a search for freedom always lead to a carceral state?

The reason is that the biggest freedom that liberalism seeks is freedom from human nature. This is true for any liberalism, be it Stalinist socialism or the neoliberal socialism of Zoran Mandani and AOC. Erasing the differences between men and women and breaking the limitations of the human body in the Stakanovite push for unlimited productivity were eagerly championed by Stalinism. The socialist neoliberals of today believe in the freedom to choose your sex. They believe that the limitations of inborn intelligence can be erased and that freedom from every physiological characteristic should be the ultimate goal of humans that justifies any kind of refashioning of society.

Nature is intractable, however. You cannot be free from it. If you’re a liberal, you get a choice: either you accept that your movement is doomed to failure from the get-go, or you have to pretend that your goals are achievable. This pretense is a delicate bubble that can be broken by anybody who refuses to participate. Soon enough, you need a large coercive apparatus that will prevent people from saying that your Stakhanovite record is as fake as Ellen Page’s penis.

Because a liberal’s goals are based on denying not only objective but physical reality, they are unreachable. If I decide to increase my productivity by working 27 hours a day, I will fail no matter what I do. And if I say I achieved it, everybody will laugh at me and call me a liar and a fantasist. The only way for me to have everybody recognize that I achieved that and pay me for my 27 hours of daily work is to force people to do so.

If I can’t control the totality of physical reality to achieve total freedom, I will have to control the totality of social relations to maintain the fiction that I fully bend reality to my free will.

Socialism, communism, liberalism, neoliberalism—these are all faces of human rebellion against the unfreedom of the human condition. These systems of thought sacrifice the limited freedom of what is possible to an illusion of the impossible total freedom.

Leave a Reply