I have nothing against the ban but it’s like fighting smoking by banning Camels and leaving the rest of the brands easily available. “Son, you are only 12, and I can’t have you smoking. This is terrible for your health. So no Camels from now on. Marlboros and Newports, on the other hand, go at it, little dude.”
Take Snapchat, for instance. It’s terrible for kids. Really bad. Take kids off TikTok, they’ll go on Snap. And what have we gained?
I’m leaving aside the part about “Chinese propaganda” on TikTok because it’s an argument of such extraordinary stupidity that I’m not going to address it beyond saying that we don’t need China’s help to develop the most successful propagandistic regime in history, and people who haven’t noticed that the source of the worst propaganda isn’t China are dense.
Let’s definitely ban TikTok but we have a much bigger problem. It will not be solved by government bans because there is no longer a government strong enough, not even in China. People will solve it (or not) as they see fit and can manage. Those who solve it for themselves and their children will be the cognitive elite. Those who don’t will be screwed.
It’s a very complex high-stakes project that will require a lot of individual effort over a long period of time, and most people won’t be bothered. That’s the stark reality we are hiding from amongst these boring debates about TikTok bans.