What I found curious about the MLA is that A-list celebrities, so to speak, were not nearly as good as the B-list ones.
Homi Bhabha was a bit of a disappointment but not in an expected way. He doesn’t speak in a nearly as convoluted and incomprehensible manner as he writes. In fact, he is a good, forceful, clear speaker. I didn’t have a problem with the form of his delivery but with the content. He spoke about Ta-Nehisi Coates’ book and everything he said I’d already heard before. The talk sounded like a pastiche of all of the reviews of the book, and I found no new insights in anything Bhabha said.
Rita Felski was undoubtedly the star of this MLA. She recently published a new book on theory (and I mean on, not of), and everybody else took care to bash this book in their talks. Which is already a sign of Felski’s importance because here you are, obsessing over her book while she has no idea that you exist. Felski’s own talk was good but not amazing.
The amazing talks were delivered by people who are not that famous but are on their way to making it. One session that I visited had 7 absolutely outstanding speakers. I loved all of them with a passion.
The moral of the story is that one should retire on time and open up a space for younger talent.