From a great post on methodological individualism:
As I’ve said, our political regime and our way of life invite us to reduce all spiritual masses to the individuals that constitute them. Finally, however, however much we may desire to see everywhere only rights-bearing subjects and individuals seeking their own interests, we run into a number of great collective facts that are decisive for world affairs.
People tend to refuse to see that the total is bigger than the sum of its parts. I run into this problem all the time whenever I talk about capitalism or the nation-state. People balk at hearing me say things like “whatever capital wants, capital gets.”
The resistance to the idea that there exists anything but a collection of individual wills of individual people all of whom do and want exactly what they say comes, I believe, from the vulgarized American sociology with its insistence that “studies” asking people about their motivations and desires are actually a source of truth.
What people say, however, is evidence of nothing but that they chose to emit these particular sounds at this particular time for no reason outsiders are aware of. How these people are and how their actions will contribute to collective forces that are larger than any individual’s stated desires remains unaddressed.
This is the death of actual social sciences that never doubted the existence of unstated motives and collective forces that go against the stated wishes of individuals. However much people might be saying that they want to retain the nation-state model or however much it might be in their interest to save it, collectively they are busily taking it apart. It’s only methodological individualism that prevents us from seeing this.
P.S. It’s very rewarding to find a post that actually says something valuable and contributes to my analysis after 15 minutes of sifting through the breathy posts by covert Trump admirers like all those Corey Robins, Mahan, Eschatology, and the rest of these shallow, gushy folks. But they illustrate the point of the main post perfectly. Whatever they say they want, they are part of a larger force that is working to get Trump elected.