The favorite argument of every Putinoid on the planet is this:
“If Americans can interfere in conflicts all over the world and impose their will on faraway countries, why can’t Russia? Americans are not even that good at it! They’ve made mistakes, huge ones! Isn’t it time for somebody else to offer alternatives to the flawed American approach?”
Whenever I hear a variation on this argument, I always have this fantasy of hoisting myself onto the scene of the Bolshoi Theater and starting to whine, “But why can’t I dance here if these other women can? I want to dance, too! They are not perfect! I read an article by a famous ballet critic last week who said these ballerinas made mistakes in their rendering of the Swan Lake! It’s my turn to try! We need an alternative to their flawed performance!”
On the world arena, Russians are as prepared to act as I am to perform in the Bolshoi. Nobody who is utterly inept at managing things at home can make a legitimate bid to teach others. Russians have nothing anybody in the world wants.
And what are their achievements at home? Russians haven’t even managed to prevent a quarter – that’s 25% – of Russian men from dying before reaching the age of 55. Their stats on violence against children and on rape are sky-high. They have elderly people starving to death – in the literal sense and not in the American sense of “I’m totally starving for a burger” – and hospitals that are stocked with neither the IV fluid nor even the most basic painkillers. The standard of living is abysmally poor. The inequality levels make all of the prattle about American inequality sound like a joke. All of the media are state-owned and 8 – graders are taught that the mentally ill are subhuman. There is no literature, none at all. No science, no scholarship, no literary criticism even!
When the US made its first bid for the role of the world’s next emerging superpower in 1898, this was the result of the country doing phenomenally well at home and overtaking everybody else on the planet in most categories. In terms of the economy, women’s rights, military prowess, industrialization, education, political process, cultural vibrancy, nobody was managing to catch up.
It will take Russia 200 years of hard work (which nobody there seems interested in investing) to catch up with the US of 1898, let alone the US of today. It’s much more likely that I will make it to the Bolshoi than that Russia will finally catch up.
To resume, a superpower is a country that creates ideas, technology and lifestyle that everybody else wants. Piss poor malcontent losers, however, do not a superpower make.