In my Freshman Seminar, I’m teaching my students – among many other things – how to approach the reading of different kinds of texts. Today, we will talk about reading history and will then try to apply the rules I list in this post to Bartolome de Las Casas’s A Brief Account of the Destruction of the Indies.
Here are the basic rules of reading about history that I’m planning to offer to my students:
Things to remember when reading, watching or researching history:
a. There can never be a fully objective account of history
b. Don’t read accounts of history to find out what happened. Read them to discover what their author says happened
c. Only by accessing and contrasting different accounts can we figure out what took place
d. Every account of history is always ideological
e. There is always a hidden reason for why a person writes about history
Questions to ask:
- Who is the author?
- What do I know about this author? Country of origin, political affiliation, profession, etc.
- How does this knowledge about the author change my understanding of his or her text?
- What is the goal the author is trying to achieve with this text?
- What kind of data is used to support the author’s conclusions?
- What kind of attitude does the author have towards the readers of the text?
- What are the central concepts that organize the author’s thinking about this subject?
Is there anything else I should add? Feel free to offer suggestions (or dispute what I have written here, of course).