Reader Stille left a link to a really great article on aggressive policing that goes on in blogging communities. Here is an excerpt:
What aroused my concern was the fact that there are too many people, in the trans community alone, who feel like they are unable to call it their community and find shelter there because the tenor of discourse is so corrosive as to be just as stressful and antagonistic as the outside world. I hear this from a number of people who are close to me and have contributed mightily to activist communities with labour, art, and struggle– and I hear it from neophytes and outsiders who wish to join but find themselves put off by the rancour they hear from within.
This talented blogger is talking about the trans community but the passage works just as well if you substitute “trans” for “academic” or “feminist”, just to name the two blogging communities I’m most familiar with. I’m sure there are others.
The moment I smell even the teensiest whiff of a self-righteous tone in a comment by somebody who staggered into my blog by accident and decided that it’s a good idea to tell me to “check my privilege” or use some other equally idiotic platitude on me, I kick that loser off my blog. I’ve seen many good blogs turn into veritable cesspools where a badgered blogger keeps apologizing profusely for hurting the imaginary sensibilities of some unhinged busybody. The need to belong is so intense for many people that they can’t even conceive of telling the policing losers to stuff it.
This happens all the time on the Liberal side of the blogosphere where many people are terrified of offending the Gods of political correctness while others appoint themselves to be the enforcers of the “correct” way to worship the jealous deities. I don’t know if the same happens on conservative websites or if people feel more entitled to shut up the defenders of The Only True Way to Opine.