When I first started writing about the imminent collapse of the nation-state, readers started asking me, “But why do you discount the possibility that the civil society might have anything to say about these changes?”
I don’t believe that a civil society is compatible with the society of consumers but I’m always ready to recognize my mistakes. So I’ve been on the lookout for evidence that a civil society exists and that it is willing to suffer some minor discomfort in order to retain some vestiges of the nation-state. When the nation-state model collapses for good, the social stratification will soar. Everybody realizes it and expresses concern. Is anybody ready to do anything about it, I wondered?
The answer is a resounding NO. I was right this entire time: the civil society is a myth. There is no way whatsoever to get anybody even just to consider holding on to what was good about the nation-state. My poignant posts on the destruction of the public university were met with stony indifference on the part of people working at that university. The suggestions on the steep inheritance tax, forced “volunteering”, the destruction of professionalism and labor unions by bored amateurs, etc are all greeted with an invariable, “But it’s more convenient this way.”
And that’s fine, I guess. If everybody is ready for the nation-state to go, I don’t want to be a silly old Luddite who fusses about a welcome change. There are many attractive qualities in the new state model. For one, the variety of goods and services will really soar once the concept of worker rights recedes into oblivion. The fortunate will be able to live more intensely than ever, shifting from one location, profession, identity, etc into another. The highly mobile, brilliantly educated class will have the best kind of existence ever experienced by anybody in history. Everybody else will be happy, too, with their plasma-screen TVs and smartphones. The social ties will be broken, and “me and my convenience” will be the most popular religion. And social activism will mean “making losers contort eagerly and ridiculously by throwing them some crumbs.” The next big political protests will be organized by a bored millionaire who will find it entertaining to force the equally bored workers to put on a show of political activism.
Come to think of it, it’s all here already, and everybody is perfectly happy.