Everybody is talking about the teaching track, and I want to contribute some ideas to the discussion.
I believe that the teaching track is a great idea. At my university, for instance, we have many people who got hired and tenured when we were still a 100% teaching institution. Things have changed, and now everybody is required to do research.
Obviously, you can’t become a research scholar overnight. Being a research scholar is a way of life. You need to accumulate intellectual capital and construct a scholarly base over the course of many years. So people who are asked to start producing scholarship at the age of 50 feel completely lost. They experience shame, fear, and stress as they try to come up with something to put in the research column of their yearly evaluation.
By the way, I met people like these both at Yale and Cornell, and now their careers are ruined because you can only fake being a research scholar for a while. So this happens everywhere, and it happens a lot.
Wouldn’t it be great to let such people off the research hook and simply give them a 4/4 or a 5/5 teaching load? And give people like me a 2/2 teaching load? That would make every sense.
However, there are three major issues that will make the introduction of a teaching track impossible:
1. There is absolutely no way of justifying the need to have people with PhDs teach Spanish 101 , Composition 101 or French 102. And people who do no research can’t teach anything else.
2. There is absolutely no way of justifying the need for tenure for people who only teach Geography 101 and Co.
3. There is absolutely no way of introducing the teaching track without making people angry and wounding their pride. People will freak out and start plotting like their lives depend on it.
And thus, this great idea will die an untimely death.
Unless students magically start coming to college more prepared, somebody will need to be doing all the remediation. That’s just reality. And all of the endless complaining about the horrible unfairness of the unkind universe will not change it. Some sort of an arrangement will have to be made to accommodate this reality. The discussion of the teaching track is at least an attempt to consider a solution. So it’s a step in a good direction.