My blogroll has been going nuts for days over the Jenner Vanity Fair cover. It might seem weird that people would get so emotionally invested but there is a reason why this happens.
The fluid world has destroyed community. And when community is not there to provide guidelines for one’s conduct and enforce compliance, all that’s left to help people figure out how to live is identity.
When Jenner (or anybody else) demonstrates that identity is as easy to sweep away as community has been, panic sets in. Identity is the very last line of defense against the increasingly fluid world. Without it, there is nothing outside of oneself to grasp for support as one is being carried along and battered by the uncontrollable flows of an insecure world.
Identity will not survive fluidity. But many people don’t know this. All they see is that the very last certainty, the very last set of guidelines they had to orient them in this confusing world is being taken away. And that is too terrifying for them to accept.