Somebody asked me the other day why I consider Elizabeth Warren a populist. Here is an example of her pronouncements that make me cringe:
Here we are, the richest country on earth — we have so much going for us, and yet we have a federal government that works great for millionaires, it works great for billionaires, it works great for giant corporations. It works great for anybody who can hire an army of lobbyists, an army of lawyers, give lots of campaign money. For the rest of America, it’s just not working.
This is garbage, people. This is overwrought, self-pitying garbage that I detest. Everything works great for me and for every single person I know. And it’s obvious that things are working beautifully for Elizabeth Warren, as well.
There is a lot of really bad shit in this country. Poverty, horrible, hopeless slums, segregation. And all this has got to be addressed. But it won’t be addressed by the self-pitying “us against the billionaires” melodrama because things are a lot more complicated than that.
I was driving through East St Louis a while ago and I saw this woman on the porch of a dilapidated house. East St Louis is a slum, in case you didn’t know. The chances of a person there becoming a victim of violent crime is one in 28, more than ten times higher than in the rest of the state. I don’t know what needs to happen for me to find the cynicism and the shamelessness to say that I know anything about the hardship faced by that woman on the porch. She and I are not in the same boat just because neither of us is a billionaire.
I don’t believe for a second that Warren is speaking to the people in East St Louis or Gary, Indiana (another horrible slum that I’ll never forget.) She is speaking to spoiled middle-class folks who love the “99% vs 1%” slogan because it makes them feel less guilty about the existence of the slums. When they say, “We are all dispossessed compared to the millionaires on Wall Street,” they conveniently erase the uncomfortable fact that some of us are a lot more dispossessed than others.
This is the nature of populism today. It’s all about allowing people to wallow in self-pity and, in return for a chance to feel like victims, they love you. And I hate this shit.