On my trip to DC, I finally had some time to check out the novel that is attracting so much attention. After reading it, I can’t say I know what the hullabaloo is about. My Brilliant Friend is a solid but unremarkable addition to the genre of childhood and adolescence novels. I read a lot of this kind of thing when I was a kid because back in the USSR this was a genre that produced quite a bit of decent writing. Literature for adults and about adults was way too controlled ideologically while books about kids could avoid being quite as ideological. (They were still ideological, of course, but not to the crazy extent of the rest of available literature.)
The problem with this genre is that it is tied to the stages of human growth and ends up being way too scripted as a result. First toys, first friendships, first day at school, first fight, first book, pimples, insecurities, sexual awakening, first kiss, etc., etc. You can switch around a couple of these stages but that’s pretty much the only variation that the genre allows.
There are a few ways of livening up this otherwise limited genre. One could work on the language to turn a pedestrian account of “she goes to school, she comes back from school, she does homework, she plays with her friends” into something a bit more like an actual work of art. One could set the childhood and adolescence in an interesting time in history and show how historic events shape the process of a child’s growth. Ferrante doesn’t do anything like that. History is even less than an afterthought in her novel, the writing is extremely straightforward, and the novel ends up being just like a million other childhood and adolescence novels.
Don’t get me wrong, it’s a very good, decent contribution to the genre. If I read this book at the age of 12, I’d be all over it. I definitely recommend getting this book for an actual child or adolescent but I’m not sure what use an adult can derive from it other than relying on the novel for an undemanding beach or airport read.