I can never figure out why people behave the way they do at social gatherings. For instance, I often find myself in the following situation.
“I completely disagree with what Jack Peters said about enrollment caps,” I venture at a social gathering.
In response, people act as if they have lived their entire lives until now eagerly awaiting an opportunity to badmouth Jack Peters.
“Oh, that Jack Peters!” they exclaim. “He’s so annoying! I heard that he once totally yelled at a colleague for no reason. And he’s such a gossip! Everybody at his department detests him! Oh, I can’t stand this fellow.”
When I see what my remark about enrollment caps did to Jack’s reputation, I always try to repair the situation.
“Well, I disagree with Jack Peters’s position on enrollment caps,” I say, “But he’s a good person. Students love him, and he’s a great colleague.”
Then everybody begins to act as if they lived their entire lives waiting for a chance to say something nice about Jack.
“Yes, Jack Peters might come off a bit gruff but that’s only because he’s had a difficult life. He has a heart of gold, that fellow. Always so helpful and understanding.”
“Of course what he said about enrollment caps is something I simply can’t agree with,” I continue.
In response, people act like Jack Peters shot their favorite dog and buried it in his backyard. And so the merry-go-round can go on for quite a while.
And I’m left wondering whether people do this because
A. The social code requires people to agree with everything they hear at such gatherings.
B. People think I’m unstable and are afraid of antagonizing me with disagreement.
C. People are extremely torn on the subject of Jack Peters’s personality.
D. Something else.