Everybody is appalled about Obama’s kill lists. They are illegal, dangerous, horrible.
Yes, they are all that. However, my question is: what is the alternative?
I see only two alternative courses of action. One, is the tried and trusty route of invasion. Do you want the US to keep invading the countries that it doesn’t like (call them undemocratic, dictator-ridden, Communist, terrorist, whatever you like, terminology is not important right now)? We all know that this is not economically sustainable at the moment and is not likely to become sustainable any time soon. Besides, this has become so outdated that the two recent endeavors in this direction bore very little desired fruit.
The other possibility is for the US to give up its belief in its exceptionalism and its role in managing the world’s affairs. Taking into account how wedded the regular Americans are to this belief and how fierce the economic competition between the US, China and India is about to become, what are the chances of that, in your opinion?
In mine, they are less than nil.
So here are our options at this point:
1. Withdraw from neo-colonial expansion, somehow change the entire national identity of the country and convince every American that is a good thing, concentrate exclusively on internal affairs, experience a dramatic lowering of the standards of living, witness the world’s hegemony of China or India. (I can’t say which one right now, what do you think?)
2. Keep to the strategies of the XXth century which mean military invasions with the attendant military, economic, and domestic costs.
3. Modernize the nature of your involvement through drone strikes, kill lists, and similarly appalling things we will see in the nearest future.
Are we really surprised that Obama is going for Option#3?
Nothing is easier than to whine that invading countries is wrong and drone strikes are evil. Yes, they are very wrong and extremely evil. Tell me instead how willing you are to put your money where you mouth is in the most literal way possible. How prepared are you to face the costs of living in a country that is not the world leader but a fairly insignificant, one-among-many place?
Everything comes at a price. Everything. Of course, it must be lots of fun to pretend the leaders you elected are doing these things out of inexplicable weirdness and not in order to give you what you insist on having.