Žižek (whose recent book I’m enjoying to the point of wanting to bug everybody with it all day long) has some interesting things to say about Israel:
In order to ground its Zionist politics, the State of Israel is here making a catastrophic mistake: it decided to downplay, if not outright ignore, so-called “old” (traditional European) anti-Semitism, focusing instead on the “new” and allegedly “progressive” anti-Semitism masked as critique of the Zionist politics of the State of Israel.
This is happening against the background of growing “old-style” anti-Semitism in Europe. Let’s remember that it was precisely that kind of anti-Semitism that led to the Holocaust not so long ago. Nobody is saying that the Holocaust is about to repeat itself in Europe, but the trend is definitely scary and needs to be addressed. Instead of doing so, however, Israel has identified the greatest enemy of the Jewish people elsewhere:
Zionism itself, in its hatred of those Jews who do not fully identify with the politics of the State of Israel, paradoxically became anti-Semitic, for it has constructed the figure of the Jew who doubts the Zionist project along anti-Semitic lines.
A really disturbing part of this process are Israel’s welcoming gestures towards openly anti-Semitic Christian fundamentalists who support the Zionist project for reasons of their own.
And finally Žižek dares to say what I always wanted to say but never mustered the strength to do:
However, are not the real self-haters those who secretly hate the true greatness of the Jewish nation, precisely the Zionists who have allied themselves with anti-Semites?
The true greatness of the Jewish nation has been reduced, in my opinion, to pursuing the boring nationalistic dream of “one’s own country” as if the Jewish people hadn’t achieved so much without this crutch and haven’t called almost every country in the world our own. Now we are supposed to self-immolate on the altar of claiming ownership to a miserable little piece of land. And those who feel it isn’t worth all these sacrifices are traitors and self-haters.
As everybody who has read this blog for a while knows, I don’t like anything anybody ever has to say about Israel. Žižek’s words, however, make a lot of sense to me. And when he says that
at the end of this road lies an extreme possibility that should in no way be excluded a priori—that of a “historic pact” between Zionists and Muslim fundamentalists,
this possibility does not sound completely unrealistic either. When The Nation (and I don’t mean the magazine) becomes a goal and a value in itself, every other consideration tends to slip away. The Jews who had to pay such an enormous price for Germany’s nationalistic drive should remember this lesson of history.