The Fallacy of Forgiveness

The brilliant Alice Miller on the fallacy of forgiveness:

Some therapists work under the influence of various interpretations culled from both Western and Oriental religions, which preach forgiveness to the once-mistreated child. Thereby, they create a new vicious circle for people who, from their earliest years, have been caught in the vicious circle of pedagogy . This, they refer to as “therapy”. In so doing, they lead them into a trap from which there is no escape, the same trap that once rendered their natural protests impossible, thus causing the illness in the first place. Because such therapists. . . cannot help patients to resolve the consequences of the traumatization they have suffered, they offer them traditional morality instead.

Remember, a therapist who is a professional and not a quack will never ever ever push you to forgive.

The idea that forgiving is somehow morally superior to not forgiving, to holding on to a grudge, to feeling anger is a means of social control. And every time you praise somebody for forgiving or push yourself to forgive you reinforce structures of oppression.

See more of this great article here.

One thought on “The Fallacy of Forgiveness

  1. Finally, someone who gets it. I don’t forgive or forget, I can hold a grudge for a long time and people get freaked out. If someone hurts me or is a horrible person, I want to crush them, I can’t forgive. That’s part of the reason I am not a Catholic, I can’t be nice to people who hurt me or are assholes. I think it’s more acceptable for a man to be vengeful than a woman, we’re supposed to be nice to assholes.

    Like

Leave a reply to ladyfiaran Cancel reply