Holocaust Studies: From Siberia to Palestine

Everybody probably knows this but I had no idea, and I’m really taken by the story. Throughout WWII, the British prohibited Jews from coming to Palestine. Still, a group of Zionist Jews managed to get there and start fighting for a Jewish state.

These Jews had been kept by Stalin in concentration camps in Siberia. When Stalin allowed Polish prisoners in the GULAG to form an army to fight against Germans, these Polish Jews joined.

For obvious reasons, Stalin couldn’t let Poles fight on the Eastern front, so he sent this small Polish army to the Western front. The Jews who were part of this Polish military force marched all the way from Siberia, through India and Iran, and to Palestine. Menachem Begin was actually one of them. These Jews entered Palestine because they were wearing the Allied forces uniform, and the British could do nothing.

This is such a powerful, beautiful story that I can’t get over it.

Idiocy Spreads

Wow, globalization helps spread idiocy extremely fast. Not two days ago, self-righteous American twitterers and facebookers started hectoring people who expressed support for France for not expressing the same support for the victims of the terror attack in Lebanon. [I discussed what I think about these finger-waggers here.]

Today, this same form of didactic and self-satisfied lecturing made its way onto the only remaining somewhat dissident TV channel in Russia. The Russians haven’t caught on to Lebanon yet, so people were chided for caring more about Paris than the victims of the Boko Haram acts of terror in Nigeria. Of course, Russian-speakers tend to be a lot more blunt and honest about this sort of thing, so the response to the Russian finger-waggers was much stronger than anything we ever hear in the West. 

I only wish it were as easy to spread intelligent ideas as it is these stupid exercises in moral superiority.

Why Do the Terrorists Hate France?

One of the vicious animals who inspired the Friday acts of terror in Paris told the terrorists to kill all Americans and Europeans they can, and “especially the filthy French.” [Note the word “filthy.”] The ISIS press release on the attack insistently linked France with prostitution.

When we all started asking ourselves why France keeps being hit by terrorists, the answers that came to mind reflected our own way of understanding the world: they hit France because it was bombing ISIS in Syria, they hit France because there are many grandchildren of Algerian immigrants from the 1960s, they hit France because there are Syrian refugees there, etc.

The mentality of the terrorists is very different, though. They talk of the “especially filthy French” and target France because of the 18th-19th-century stereotype of France as a place of sexual libertinage. This is not the first time that ISIS betrays a very late 18th – early 19th-century mentality*. There is a lot to study here, but our understanding is often clouded by the need to imagine everybody in the world as mirror images of ourselves.

*People say ISIS represents medieval Islam but I’m not seeing that at all. The Caliphate of Córdoba they are trying to recreate was the polar opposite of what they are actually doing.

Holocaust Studies: Talking about Anti-Semitism

President Obama has spoken about the environment on campuses, and this is the part that caught my attention:

And I say to them, Listen, if you hear somebody using a racial epithet, if you hear somebody who’s anti-Semitic, if you see an injustice, I want you to speak out, and I want you to be firm and clear, and I want you to protect people who many not have voices themselves.

It’s very refreshing to see the President mention anti-Semitism. It has become fashionable amongst the most obnoxious among my fellow progressives to roll eyes and make weird clucking sounds whenever anti-Semitism is mentioned. This is a subject that, at best, gets a yes-butting from people who can wax enthusiastic for hours about any other sort of oppression, including every imaginary one.

Things have gotten to the point where people see a building defaced with a swastika and still can’t squeeze out the word “anti-Semitism.” Let’s hope that Obama’s words, at least, will have an impact.

Fashion for Muslim Women in Russia

image

There must be a reason why Putin is dressed in something resembling a Nazi uniform in the applique but that’s a question for the designer.

Yale Protest Brings Results

Yale protests have culminated in the administration allocating $50,000,000 to. . . expanding the administration. For comparison’s sake, this amount would suffice to fund 100% for half a century my entire department that teaches seven different languages.

Yale Corporation is incredibly rich, so who cares if it blows this amount on expanding its bureaucracy? The problem is that once the tradition sets in of having all of these endless inclusion centers and diversity seminars, everybody begins to be forced into the same administrative patterns. And university like mine already has to treasure every 5 bucks it has (literally!). Taking away even more resources from actual education can be ruinous. 

What’s annoying is that once again black students who are in actual need of the education we provide will be short-changed to make a bunch of rich kids at Yale feel important.

Putin’s Repetitive Search

‘We will find them anywhere on the planet and punish them,’ Putin said of the plane bombers at a somber Kremlin meeting broadcast on Tuesday. The FSB security service swiftly announced a $50 million bounty in a global manhunt for the bombers.”

The cockroach has started to repeat himself. The last time it was, “We will find them anywhere on the planet and punish them, we will find them even in the toilet, and kill them in the toilet”, said a propos of Chechen terrorists. The famous toilet phrase got Putin unwavering love of Russians who, until then, were only vaguely aware of his existence.

What Russians failed to notice in their fantasy of killing Chechens in the toilet was how eagerly Putin allowed the Chechens to create a criminal state of religious fanatics in Chechnya and how happy he is to pay them an enormous tribute and allow them to conduct criminal activities in Moscow in return for not turning their de facto independence into a de jure one.

Yes, he is such a mighty opponent of terrorists. They must be shaking in their boots, poor sods.

Low-carb Suggestions

People, if you are on a low-carb diet for reasons of health or weight loss, I highly recommend going to an Indian buffet. Just skip anything bread-related, use shredded lettuce and fresh cucumbers instead of rice as a basis for the meal, and you can pig out to your heart’s content.

Holocaust Studies: Just-like-Holocausters

Middle schoolers who join debate teams are warned to avoid the “that’s just like Hitler” argument because it’s intellectually vacuous and morally unsustainable. Reaching out for an easy, tear-jerking analogy is a sign of an impotent mind.

Lazy, primitive brains love nothing as much as they do analogy. They dismiss any new information that reaches them with an, “Oh, it’s just like X” because absorbing anything new is work, and it’s much easier to sift through a limited stock of trivia tidbits than try to learn. The Hitler Analogy is the easiest one because every ignoramus on the planet feels hugely knowledgeable about the Holocaust on the basis of having heard that something vaguely bad might have happened and can be used to shame people you don’t like.

This morning, I tried scrolling through my news feed but all I saw, in about 30 articles in a row, was the comparison of Syrian refugees with European Jews in 1938. The analogy is both unsustainable and offensive. It’s also been done to death, it sheds no light on the understanding of anything, yet people repeat it with the insistence of robots who’ve had no other function programmed into them.

Have you noticed, though, that for just-like-Holocausters everything is as bad as the Holocaust except for the Holocaust? They have no sympathy for Jews but every sympathy for just-like-Jews. (One of the just-like-Holocausters in my blogroll, for instance, was the “tender – hearted Nazis” fellow I quoted yesterday.)

The reason is that their attachment to just-like-Holocausting does not only serve the purpose of faking an understanding where there is none. It also helps them trivialize the Holocaust and turn it into an ordinary, mundane occurrence which is “just like” everything else in the world.