Advertisements

Clarissa's Blog

An academic's opinions on feminism, politics, literature, philosophy, teaching, academia, and a lot more.

Psychology of Democracy

Donald Winnicott, the great psychologist of early infancy, studied democracy from the psychological point of view. He said, among many other things, that the erosion of national boundaries, the idea of unchecked global flows, and the concept of a world government create extreme anxiety in psychologically healthy individuals. Boundaries are extremely important to a healthy psyche. The incapacity to tolerate boundaries is indicative of a whole host of psychopathologies. He wrote this back in 1949, or around that date, by the way. 

Also, he said that the idea of a woman in the highest position of political power in democratic societies is perceived as disturbing by many psychologically healthy individuals. It subconsciously returns them to the earliest memories of when the mother was the all-powerful entity in their lives, holding the power of life and death over them. (The awareness of the father as a separate being from the mother develops at a later stage). The desire to judge female politicians at the highest level by a different standard is neither malicious nor malignant. It’s simply a reflection of the journey that a human psyche makes in the process of its formation. 

To develop Winnicott’s idea, berating people for having these feelings reinforces the perception of their being in the presence of a scolding, disapproving mother. This is clearly counterproductive for a female politician. There is a whole field of study here waiting to be discovered that would come up with strategies to work with this reality instead of denouncing it. 

Another thing he said is that societies with a great number of healthy, normal, happy families are better at democracy than societies where unhealthy family dynamics are prevalent. 

These are just a few tiny observations on what is a complex and important work of a great psychologist.

Advertisements

Single Post Navigation

19 thoughts on “Psychology of Democracy

  1. I’d like you to give us the references for the Winnicott ideas that you are basing this one as they seem intriguing

    Like

    • He started developing these ideas in 1949 in an article (I don’t remember the title), then wrote about them throughout the 1950s and in 1965 dedicated a chapter to the issue in the book titled The Family and Individual Development. I think it’s Chapter 7, if I’m not mistaken.

      Like

  2. Shakti on said:

    1)So Lakoff, but much more annoying?

    2) Merkel is going to have a very tough time but she’ll have been Chancellor for 17 years in about two days.

    3)

    Liked by 2 people

    • I never heard about Lakoff.

      Merkel offers a great case study in what I discussed in this post. I’m personally not very interested in her but somebody should do the analysis.

      Like

      • Shakti on said:

        Lakoff believes that people respond to political figures and parties based on a strict father/nuturant mother framework of families. Democrats are the “Mommy” party and Republicans are the “Daddy” party and people vote based on which framework appeals most to them.
        I’m vastly oversimplifying.
        Understanding Trump

        Lakoff is big on frames — if you just frame it right, people will listen. Well, maybe.

        Like

        • I’m happy to look at anything that departs from the supremely boring shrieks about “racistsexists.”

          Like

          • \ I’m happy to look at anything that departs from the supremely boring shrieks about “racistsexists.”

            I liked his advice to “not to repeat false conservative claims and then rebut them with the facts. Instead, go positive.”

            Another proposal is more controversial, but at least partly correct:

            “Give up identity politics. No more women’s issues, black issues, Latino issues. Their issues are all real, and need public discussion. But they all fall under freedom issues, human issues. And address poor whites! Appalachian and rust belt whites deserve your attention as much as anyone else. Don’t surrender their fate to Trump, who will just increase their suffering.”

            Also, while I was reading Tuvia’s book, I noticed the similarity between black, Latino and poor whites issues. All of them live in horrible environments without normal chance to find a decent job, without hope for something better.

            As an aside, Tuvia checked how the poor faired in the Obama’s former district, and the poor people there don’t think Obama helped them. Only one small boy (<10 years old) told life is better now than more than a decade ago because there are more food stamps.

            Like

      • The oddest thing about Merkel in this regard is that everyone in Germany seems to be completely conscious of the fact she is a mother figure. People regularly and only sort of jokingly refer to her as Mutti (Mommy), it’s been going on for many years, and it’s wide spread and comfortable enough that other parties use it in their add campaigns (I have an anti-Merkel “Tschüss Mutti!” sticker from the Green Party somewhere in my office), and it regularly gets used in headlines by the less serious newspapers. As someone who follows German news but hasn’t lived in Germany for a very long time, I find the whole thing totally bizarre.

        Like

    • Shakti on said:

      I’m not sure how much these decisions are driven by deep indications of psychological health. I am not someone’s mother or therapist so the projections of everyone’s mommy issues onto me whenever I try to assume authority annoys me.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Dreidel on said:

    Well, for whatever reason, motherly (or grandmotherly) women “in the highest position of political power in democratic societies” aren’t doing so well lately. Theresa May, Merkel, and Hillary come to mind…

    Like

    • Hey, it’s not like men are doing much better. Putin, Maduro, Kim Jong-un, or whatever his name, Modi, the list is endless. Democracy stinks. But everything else, etc, etc.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: