Way Too Healthy

Turns out JD Salinger was a health food nut and a practicing homeopath. His understanding of healthy eating was very touchingly American.

He was adamantly opposed to eating anything but nuts, seeds, raw vegetables, and raw milk. Rarely, he’d consent to cheese. Nothing processed, nothing with sugar, and nothing cooked at over 150°F. No coffee. No beverages at all except water. And, incomprehensibly, no tomatoes, not even the raw variety.

The only exception to these rules were popcorn, bagels, and smoked salmon. It would not occur to anybody but an American, and a Jewish American at that, to list these as indispensable and healthier than tomatoes.

8 thoughts on “Way Too Healthy

  1. I also avoid/limit tomatoes; I do so because they are a nightshade vegetable. I also limit or avoid potatoes and eggplants for that same reason. Some people, I think I’m among them, that have psoriasis experience ‘psoriasis flares’ if the consume too much nightshade vegetables.

    My diet is not quite a constrained as Salinger’s but nearly so. A lot of whole grains, no dairy (also associated with psoriasis flares) but lots of non dairy yogurt and milk, beans, oily fish and vegetables with exclusions.

    It has been a healthy diet for me and seems to have limited flares although I can not say that it has eliminated them all.

    Like

    1. My main thing here is how come popcorn and bagels are healthier than … anything, pretty much? Popcorn is the definition of junk. And bagels are about the worst bread you can find.

      I’m very glad you are controlling the psoriasis so well!!

      Like

  2. Tomatoes are a common reflux trigger. Not saying that this was necessarily the case for Salinger, but I can absolutely see someone with severe reflux or GERD cutting out acidic foods like tomatoes.

    Like

  3. Yeah, raw tomatoes give me hives, but cooked is okay. Helped my wife grow a couple of dozen plants every year. Mostly Romas for canning, but a couple of heritage Brandywines for fresh eating. A good one is almost the size of a softball. On warm afternoons, she and the adopted kids would sit on the picnic table with a salt shaker and eat them, happy as clams ;-D

    Like

Leave a reply to Ed Frey Cancel reply