I read a lot of police procedural mysteries for fun. This is the golden era for readers because there is an abundance of excellent self-published books on Kindle Unlimited. It’s great for authors, too, because they don’t need to depend on agents or publishers.
One thing I observe in the police procedural genre, be it written by an establishment or an indie author, is that the female protagonist is always the same person. She is a promiscuous, physically aggressive, socially inept, spartan slob. I’ve been reading these novels for decades, and they are all great but identical in this one respect.
This is not the authors’ fault. They have to write for a female audience because that’s 99% of the readership. This means they can’t have a male cop protagonising the series because you either make him a total eunuch or female readers will not accept him and won’t read. My favorite author in the genre, Sophie Hannah, found the perfect formula to keep female readers content. Her male protagonist is incapable of having sex because of childhood trauma. Her female heroine is extremely promiscuous but only because she’s in love with the male character who can’t have sex.
Just finished reading The Punishment She Deserves on your recommendation, and I do like that about Havers: she’s not that character.
LikeLike
“the female protagonist”
Is a man…. all of the traits you describe are conventions for describing the traditional male detective…
How very odd…..
LikeLiked by 1 person
Absolutely. They are men in everything but their genitals. It’s a convention of the genre that nobody is managing to escape.
Barbara Havers, mentioned in another comment, is not promiscuous. But she’s an insensitive, socially stunted slob all right.
LikeLike
LOL, damn, it is no wonder why mere “insensitive, socially stunted slob”s just might have some difficulties understanding others’ minds ;-D
LikeLike
I think you have come down too hard on Detective Sergeant Barbara Havers. I might agree that she comes off as insensitive but a socially stunted slob? That is striking too close to home since I like her.
LikeLike