The Karmelo Anthony Trial

That the judge is allowing a political litmus test which is entirely unrelated to the actual court case under consideration is a very bad sign.

2 thoughts on “The Karmelo Anthony Trial

  1. Although we’re politically simpatico, I don’t find allowing this type of inquiry unusual. In a 55 year career, I would often ask completely “off the wall” questions in voire dire, thus stimulating honest, not canned, responses. For example: ‘Do you have a pet at home?’ is a better way to assess a juror’s capacity for empathy, than conventionally “relevant” questions, which usually generate dull, rote, responses of no use to the litigator.

    Like

    1. This question is simply another way of asking, “Are you a Trump supporter?” This is very different than asking about pet ownership. I don’t think it would be allowed to ask directly about a person’s voting record. So this is a way to bypass that.

      Like

Leave a comment