Once citizenship loses all meaning, there won’t be any rights any more, for anybody. Is that clear or do I need to explain this again? This is very, very important. Nothing is probably quite as important, so let’s stay with it for a moment.
There are no abstract “human rights” floating in the air. That’s a myth, a rhetorical device. The only real rights are the ones your nation-state is willing to guarantee to you as a citizen. Once the distinctions between citizen and non-citizen are eroded, it doesn’t mean everybody gets more rights. It means everybody gets fewer. The form of statehood that perceives every citizen as endowed with rights just for existing is very recent. It’s a historical anomaly. It’s not a naturally occurring phenomenon, just like good roads and clean streets aren’t. It can go away very easily.
Now is a very good time to get our emotions under control and concentrate on how we preserve this unique and fragile state form. Talking about “human rights” at this point is almost as embarrassing as using the phrase “global citizen.” The nation-state is wounded. We have turned away from it and put it on the brink of going out of existence. It might still be not too late to undo the damage. We should concentrate on that, on asking ourselves what do we give in exchange for unprecedented rights and unprecedented standard of living to this form of statehood. What do we give to our nation-state that a different form of statehood couldn’t easily coerce out of us while offering nothing in return?