I don’t believe, by the way, that the US is obligated to avenge a dead Russian dissident as a matter of principle. Or defend Ukraine from a Russian invasion, for that matter.
What I do believe is that if an American president made a very public promise, or if the US signed treaties and agreements, these promises and agreements should be honored.
The US signed the Budapest Memorandum and then spent 20 years aggressively coercing Ukraine to disarm and promising to defend it if Russia invaded. Once you incur an obligation, you have to follow through. If you don’t want to or can’t do that, then simply don’t incur obligations. Don’t promise, don’t sign, don’t foam at the mouth.
This isn’t unreasonable or too much to ask. The US placed itself between Ukraine and Russia since 1990. And then stayed there all through the Clinton, Bush and Obama presidencies. Then in 2014 we suddenly discovered that all those promises, including the very recent ones, were bunkum.
This is why I’m so annoyed by the “not my war” slogan. It very much is your war because your country made this war possible through consistent, open, decades-long policy. A nation-state by definition conducts foreign policy. You can’t have a nation-state while simultaneously saying, “I personally didn’t make these promises, so it has nothing to do with me.”
“I’m an individual and not bound by the social contract of my nation-state” is a post-national approach. And post-national means “open-border.” Because if there’s no nation, there can be no border like there can be no nose without a face for the nose to be located.
Not your war? Not your promises and obligations? Great. Welcome to the world without borders, police, comfort, standards of living, and everything else that the nation-state brings. Welcome to the third-world hellhole you are ushering in with your anti-national tantrums. Welcome to the world where words mean nothing and duty was obliterated by the whim of the moment. I hope you enjoy it since you worked so hard to bring it about.






