Book Notes: Harry Kemelman’s Friday the Rabbi Slept Late

This is the first in a series of mystery novels about Rabbi David Small. The mystery in this first novel in the series is nothing special. I knew who the murderer was 3 seconds after the murderer’s first appearance. But the rabbi is priceless.

The novel was written in the 1960s when there seems to have been a hope to create a way of being Jewish that lay between the Hasidic lifestyle and the completely irreligious marching-with-the-BLM and wailing-at-faculty-meetings-about-the-importance-of-pronouns lifestyle. Kemelman’s rabbi is trying to create that midway option but even in the 1960s it seems to be too late. The congregation doesn’t want rabbinical wisdom. It wants to discard every marker of Jewishness and just fit in. It’s interesting to read the novel now that we know how the story ends.

Quite a few paragraphs from the novel sound like they have been lifted straight from Rod Dreher’s blog. American Christianity is right now experiencing what American Judaism went through 60 years ago. If Kemelman’s novel is to teach us anything, it’s that Dreher is right to worry. People need to feel that their lives have a transcendent aspect. Once you erase religion from their lives, they start trying to wrench transcendence from places that aren’t suited for that purpose. The result is always ugly.

As I always say, the people who stop believing in the Savior become the Savior. And that’s very scary.

One thought on “Book Notes: Harry Kemelman’s Friday the Rabbi Slept Late

  1. “people who stop believing in the Savior become the Savior”

    I’m personally incapable of religious faith. I’ve found a way to make it work for me, but it doesn’t scale up to the general population (just like all sorts of other weird eccentricities can work as uncommon individual quirks but won’t work as societal norms).
    It seems now that American Jews chose the worst of both worlds…. rejecting both assimilation and faith. I remember when it wasn’t a big deal for otherwise observant Jewish people to celebrate the more secular aspects of Christmas (similar to the way my culturally Christian but essentially unbelieving family did) and still follow other Jewish holidays. Now it’s eating Chinese food on Christmas to be different but with no holidays that they believe in either….


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.