Clarissa's Blog

2 responses to “Reason for Joy”

1. 

   cliff arroyo

   March 19, 2023

   “joy over the earthquakes in Turkey”

   Just the other day I was interacting with someone who is still trying to find rational western-style reasons to explain russian actions. I used just that clip (and a link to Julia Davis) to show just how insane russian public discourse is.

   I can understand not getting it up to a point… but after that point… you have to wake up and smell the coffee.

   LikeLike

   Reply
2. 

   mitchellporter

   March 20, 2023

   I was motivated to research this guy. He was actually in western media a year ago, because he and another guest of Soloviev were saying that the invasion of Ukraine was a bad idea. Bagdasarov said it would be worse than Afghanistan.

   I don’t know what he’s been saying since then, but I see from his website that he’s essentially a weekly guest on the show, so he must have changed his tune somehow.

   But Turkey is his real focus. On his website, he describes himself as a “military orientalist”. He’s a Russian Armenian who grew up in the Ferghana Valley, and his whole career has involved Russia’s relations with the Islamic world.

   I’ve tried to take a long view. The Internet Encyclopedia of Ukraine suggests that Russia got its start as an expansionist power, in part by fighting with Ottoman Turkey for possession of Ukraine.

   I found an article from The Atlantic, dating from 1886, an account by a Protestant missionary of the millennial “dream of Russia” to recapture Constantinople for Christianity:

   https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1886/12/the-dream-of-russia/522855/

   The article provides many glimpses of the threeway relations between Russia, Turkey, and western Europe, during the 19th-century age of imperialism.

   Nowadays I suppose it’s more like Russia, Islam, and NATO. His remarks about Turks and Turkic people are not mysterious if one knows anything about Pan-Turkism, and Turkish ambitions after the end of the USSR.

   Wanting to recapture Constantinople in 2023 sounds insane, but I remember how many grand geopolitical schemes were declared in America during the two decades after 9/11.

   LikeLike

   Reply