
The problem is, nobody has those policies because they don’t exist. Africa is experiencing a population boom and Finland isn’t. That tells you all you need to know about the connection between policy and population growth. There’s policy to stop people from reproducing but no policy in reverse.
I have a friend from Benin who grew up with 11 siblings in a dirt-floor hut in Africa. Now she’s an American mother, and she says that she’s a mother in a completely different way than her own mom in Africa was. Her children are children in a completely different way. Our subjectivity is different in the West. We experience ourselves in the world in a radically different way. We are not a Fordist model of conveyor belt production of children. We are the artisanal model. The only way to go back to the subjectivity we left behind 200 years ago is through a cataclysm of extinction-level proportions. Obviously, we don’t want that. But what’s the problem, anyway? Why should we pursue quantity over quality at this point? Yes, it’s a good thing for people to have children. It’s normal and happy-making. But why does it need to be 10 children and not 2 or 3? Look at Elon Musk with his 14 kids that have to beg on social media for his attention. How is that better than having a real father, who’s there to play baseball with you, take you to the arcade, and make cringey but endearing Dad jokes? What is the purpose, to crunch out numbers or have an experience that brings together two different subjectivities (the parent’s and the child’s) in the most fulfilling, deep, pleasurable and enlightening manner possible? I know without a shadow of a doubt that N, for example, is enormously happier in his fatherhood than Musk because he has time and energy to build a nuanced, profound relationship with his child. Any man (but obviously almost no woman) can father a crowd of children all over the place and never care that they exist. But for what purpose? Yes, yes, I mean a man with money but you’ll notice that it’s usually the men with money who treat their fatherhood much more carefully than lazy layabouts.
So my conservative advice is let’s have children and concentrate on being good, attentive, loving parents to them. Or good, attentive, loving aunts and uncles if we don’t have kids of our own.




