I told this story before but I will repeat it in light of the Abrego García scandal.
In 2008-9 I was working as a Visiting Assistant Professor at Cornell University. My contract there was to end on May 15, 2009. My new contract at my current university was to start on August 15 of that same year. I was at that time a citizen of Canada, which means I can enter the US without a visa as a tourist.
In March of 2009, I started receiving phone calls from Homeland Security, telling me that I had to remove myself from the country on May 15 when my work contract expired. This meant I had to leave on May 15, then re-enter as a tourist (because I wanted to be with N who was working in Baltimore), then leave again and re-enter on August 15 under my new work contract. This was very inconvenient and entailed a lot of expense that I could ill-afford.
However, it was the law of the US. I respected the law and did everything legally. Left, came back, left again, and came back again. I could have easily disregarded these requirements and nobody would have hunted me around to deport me. But it would have been illegal. I don’t do illegal shit. I strongly believe that this is the only correct and moral attitude to life.
N lived for 2 years in the US on a visa that allowed him to reside but not work. He could have easily worked illegally and nobody would have known. He got requests galore for some off-the-books work. He didn’t even consider them and lived off his savings, spending everything he had managed to save. Yet between the two of us, it wasn’t even a question whether to accept work without the correct immigration status. We didn’t even discuss it, it was so obvious to both of us that we weren’t going to break the law. You know how much money he could have made in those two years? A lot. But it wasn’t even tempting because it would have been illegal.