What I find completely bizarre is how the recent developments in Hugo Schwyzer’s life are leading many people to say that now they doubt his sincerity. I have no idea how they even manage to connect sincerity to what is going on.
Even the sincerest among us can get sick. Even the most determined to stay healthy can end up in a hospital. Having a nervous breakdown does not in any way invalidate the sincerity of one’s political position or of one’s desire to be healthy. I mean, I recently developed gestational diabetes. Does that make you doubt the sincerity of my last week’s post on the separation of spheres as a patriarchal phenomenon? If so, then you are the one who belongs in a mental clinic.
The degree of earnestness you invest into an endeavor does not guarantee success. It is only the very immature who believe that trying very very hard will ensure that things will work out.
If one were to discover that Hugo had donated money to Mitt Romney’s campaign or collected signatures to shut down a Planned Parenthood clinic, then yes, people would be justified in suspecting that everything he had ever written on the subject of feminism was a lie. But having marital trouble and getting sick are in no way related to how honest one is about one’s political convictions. Or about trying to avoid getting sick or having marital trouble.
Everything said above can be applied to Hugo’s marital issues. How many relationships in your life have failed despite your completely earnest and sincere dedication to making them work? One? Two? Eight? Are those failures evidence that you were insincere all along? If so, then you need to reexamine the kind of magical thinking that leads you to invest sincerity with the power to make everything right.
And just so that I don’t have to start a new post on this subject: if you in any way care about the nature of Hugo’s marital problems and wonder if he cheated on his wife, who he cheated with, how many times, etc., you need to know that you have serious psychosexual issues that you’d be well-served to address. An emotional investment into the sex lives of anybody other than your own sex partners is not healthy.

