A student irrupted into my office and asked in an aggressive tone, “So do you have a PhD?”
“Yes,” I said. “Are you OK?”
“So if you have a PhD, can you explain to me how a command is formed in the plural for verbs followed by object pronouns?”
I’m always happy to explain grammar even if the request is made with an unwarranted degree of antagonism. So I explained and drew a little picture to illustrate.
“Hah!” the student exclaimed. “So you are saying it would be wrong to say. . .” and she used an incorrect conjugation.
“No, that would be a mistake,” I said.
“Are you sure?” the student asked even more angrily.
“Yes, I am.”
“Professor Gomez always uses this form you say is incorrect, though!” the student was triumphant.
“That’s not possible,” I said. “You probably misheard.”
“No! I heard just right! And I filmed it and uploaded the video on Facebook because I knew Professor Gomez speaks incorrectly! And now I will quote your words next to the video. Because you have a PhD and you say Professor Gomez doesn’t speak right.”
“Wait, just wait,” I said. “I’m sure you misheard because. . .”
But the student was already running away.
I now feel like I’ve been used in some weird vendetta a student has against another professor. Professor Gomez is a native speaker who speaks beautiful Spanish and cannot possibly make any grammar mistakes. Especially such ridiculous ones. And I really don’t want to appear next to any videos.




