There are things people do without having verbalized or consciously accepted their intention to do them. The lack of conscious planning, however, doesn’t make the consequences of these actions any less devastating and doesn’t relieve anybody of the responsibility for them.
The elites – politicians, journalists, public figures – are probably not saying to themselves, “Let me thin out the competition that my children will be facing by holding back as many of their peers as possible.” President Obama was surely not thinking, “The joke is on you, losers” as he made impassioned speeches about the “mistaken” belief that a college degree was necessary to get a good job, all the while planning to send his daughter to Harvard. And it’s not like anybody is doubting that she won’t stop at a single degree either.
Nobody, I’m sure, is cynical enough purposefully to feed people crippling lies about the possibility of reversing the changes that have taken place since the 1970s. But the sad truth is that there is a whole class of people who are gaining huge economic advantages from perpetuating these lies. And I’m convinced that there is an unacknowledged, unconfessed desire to keep these advantages that lies at the root of the reluctance to say, “Folks, this party is dead. Time for you to move on because I already have.”
I don’t believe that anybody who is not saying this genuinely wants to reduce inequality. I feel queasy every time I see yet another weepy article about inequality whose author reaps the benefits of feeling all moral and caring while doing everything possible to ensure that inequality grows.