The out-of-control adoption of all these ridiculous and useless “technological solutions” is one of the reasons why college tuitions are rising and professors’ salaries stagnate. I love gadgets as much – and probably more – than the next person but I am absolutely 100% convinced that clickers, schmickers, Turnitins, electronic workbooks, Quias, Supersites, and all the rest of that hugely expensive stuff are very easily dispensable.
There are schools that actually ask professors who interview for jobs what kind of “technologies” they are ready to use in the classroom. The obsession with quantification has led many administrators to believe that the quality of teaching can be measured with the number of gadgets a professor uses. This insanity is now even spreading to research, forcing people to create ridiculous “digital archives” and open positions in entirely meaningless “digital humanities” while courses on Cervantes don’t even get taught because there is no funding.
People, I’m not a Luddite. I live attached to my cell phone. My Kindle is practically a limb. And it is precisely as a result of my immersion in gadgetry that I have established with absolute certainty that good teaching does not necessitate gadgets. If you try really hard, good teaching might remain not entirely crapped up by the introduction of gadgets but that’s it.
Enormous amounts of time and money are spent on adoption, training and renunciation of technological solutions that get outdated even before they hit the market. Committees are formed, paperwork is generated, training workshops and seminars are conducted, conferences titled “Quia or Supersite?” are organized and the result of all that busyness is soaring tuition and harried, exhausted professors.
People, enough already! Let’s stop gadgeting and go back to teaching. Let’s push back whenever semi-literate bureaucrats try to make us feel deficient for not using clickers and Turnitin in our teaching. Academia belongs to us and it’s up to us to set the tone. Let’s stop worshiping on the altar of technology and start making people who push these expensive licences and gadgets on us feel ridiculous and stupid.